Relay service for communication between controllers and accessories

ABSTRACT

A relay service can relay messages between controllers and electronically controllable accessory devices that may be located remotely from the controllers. Relaying of messages by the relay service can be decoupled from any knowledge of the functionality of the accessory or the content of the messages. Device identification and relaying of messages can be managed using “relay aliases” that are meaningful only to the relay service and the endpoint devices (the controller and accessory). The endpoint devices can implement end-to-end security for messages transported by the relay service.

CROSS-REFERENCES TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

The present application is a continuation of co-pending U.S. patentapplication Ser. No. 16/105,464, filed Aug. 20, 2018, entitled, “RELAYSERVICE FOR COMMUNICATION BETWEEN CONTROLLERS AND ACCESSORIES,” which isa continuation of co-pending U.S. patent application Ser. No.15/618,707, filed Jun. 9, 2017, entitled, “RELAY SERVICE FORCOMMUNICATION BETWEEN CONTROLLERS AND ACCESSORIES,” which is acontinuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No. 15/064,406, filed Mar.8, 2016, entitled, “RELAY SERVICE FOR COMMUNICATION BETWEEN CONTROLLERSAND ACCESSORIES,” which claims priority to U.S. Provisional ApplicationNo. 62/171,995, filed Jun. 5, 2015, entitled “RELAY SERVICE FORCOMMUNICATION BETWEEN CONTROLLERS AND ACCESSORIES,” the disclosures ofwhich are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety for allpurposes.

The present disclosure is also related to the following U.S. patentapplications: U.S. application Ser. No. 14/614,914, filed Feb. 5, 2015;U.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,891, filed May 29, 2015; and U.S.application Ser. No. 14/725,912, filed May 29, 2015. The disclosures ofthese applications are also incorporated by reference herein in theirentirety for all purposes.

BACKGROUND

The present disclosure relates generally to remote control of accessorydevices and in particular to a relay service that provides securecommunication between controller devices and accessories via a publicnetwork.

Electronic devices are becoming increasingly popular in a range ofapplications. Mobile phones, tablet computers, home entertainmentsystems, and the like are just some of the electronic devices usersinteract with regularly.

Another category of electronic devices that is becoming more popularincludes various electronically controllable devices, such asthermostats, lighting devices, household appliances, etc.

Many users want to be able to interact remotely with controllabledevices. For example, some dream of being able to verify, without goingback home to check, that the oven is off or the front door is locked. Tomeet this desire, some manufacturers have begun to offer“Internet-enabled” appliances that have the ability to connect to auser's wireless local area network (e.g., a Wi-Fi network) and therebybecome accessible via the Internet. This convenience, however, is notwithout problems. For example, instances have been reported ofInternet-enabled baby monitors being hacked by pranksters who findamusement in disturbing sleeping infants. Such stories may make usersreluctant to introduce Internet-enabled appliances into their homes.

SUMMARY

Certain embodiments of the present invention relate to a relay servicethat can provide users with remote access to electronically controllabledevices (e.g., in-home devices such as a thermostat, lighting systems,home security systems, and so on). The relay service can be used toexchange messages between a “controller device” and various otherelectronically controllable devices (referred to herein as “accessorydevices” or simply “accessories”). A controller can be implemented, forexample, on a general-purpose computing device such as a desktopcomputer, laptop computer, tablet computer, smart phone, other mobilephone, other handheld device, or wearable computing device, by providingthe general-purpose computing device with appropriate executable programcode; alternatively, a controller can be a special-purpose computingdevice. An accessory can include any device that is controllable by acontroller. Examples of accessories include light fixtures, thermostats,door locks, automatic door openers (e.g., garage door opener), still orvideo cameras, kitchen appliances, and so on. The relay service can usea public, unsecured communication medium (e.g., the Internet) to receivemessages from a controller device and relay them to an accessory andvice versa.

In various embodiments, the relay service can implement features thatmay help to protect user privacy. For example, the relaying of messagesbetween a controller and accessory can be decoupled from any knowledgeof the functionality of the accessory or the content of the messages.Further, the identification of devices can be managed using “relayaliases” that are meaningful only to the relay service and the endpointdevices (the controller and accessory). In some embodiments, the relayservice can operate while remaining agnostic as to the identity (e.g.,manufacturer, model, etc.), functionality, or current state of anyaccessories. Thus, even if communications between the relay service andendpoints (or even within the relay service) are intercepted, it may notbe possible to extract information about the nature or state of anyaccessories or to determine how to communicate with any accessory.

In addition, in some embodiments, the relay service can be used as atransport by controllers and accessories to transport messages that areformatted according to a protocol (e.g., a uniform accessory protocol asdescribed below) that provides end-to-end communication security. Insome instances, the uniform accessory protocol may first require a“local” setup process to be performed while the accessory and controllerare in “local communication” with each other (i.e., communicatingwithout the aid of the relay service, e.g., via a wireless local areanetwork or personal area network), and the relay service may only becomeusable to communicate with a particular accessory after this local setupis performed. Such measures can further enhance security of the relayservice while providing users the convenience of being able to accesstheir accessory devices (e.g., home-based devices) from anywhere in theworld.

In some embodiments, the relay service can include a reporting servicethat is able to anonymously gather data relating to anomalous accessorymessaging behavior detected by the relay service. This can allow foridentification and remediation of certain types of accessorymalfunctions or faults (e.g., faulty firmware) without recording datathat would indicate which users own or use what accessories. Remediationin some instances can include temporarily (or permanently) precludingcertain accessories from connecting to the relay service.

The following detailed description together with the accompanyingdrawings will provide a better understanding of the nature andadvantages of the present invention.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 shows a home environment according to an embodiment of thepresent invention.

FIG. 2 shows a network configuration according to an embodiment of thepresent invention.

FIG. 3 shows a simplified block diagram of a relay service according toan embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 4 shows a simplified flow diagram of an accessory activationprocess according to an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 5 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process by which acontroller can obtain an operator relay alias according to an embodimentof the present invention.

FIG. 6 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process for exchangingoperator and accessory relay aliases according to an embodiment of thepresent invention.

FIG. 7 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process for relay pairingaccording to an embodiment of the present invention.

FIGS. 8A and 8B show simplified flow diagrams of processes forcommunicating request and response messages between a controller and anaccessory via a relay service according to an embodiment of the presentinvention.

FIG. 9 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process for relaying anotification from an accessory to a controller via a relay serviceaccording to an embodiment of the present invention.

FIGS. 10A and 10B show a simplified flow diagram of a process for addinga relay pairing for another user according to an embodiment of thepresent invention.

FIG. 11 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process for removing arelay pairing according to an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 12 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process for establishing aconnection between an accessory and an accessory courier serveraccording to an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 13 shows a simplified flow diagram of a diagnostic processaccording to an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 14 shows a simplified flow diagram of an investigation processaccording to an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 15 shows a simplified block diagram of a computer system accordingto an embodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 16 shows a simplified block diagram of a controller according to anembodiment of the present invention.

FIG. 17 shows a simplified block diagram of an accessory according to anembodiment of the present invention.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION Example Environment

FIG. 1 shows a home environment 100 according to an embodiment of thepresent invention. Home environment 100 includes a controller 102 thatcan communicate with various accessory devices (also referred to asaccessories) located in the environment. Controller 102 can include, forexample, a desktop computer, laptop computer, tablet computer, smartphone, wearable computing device, personal digital assistant, or anyother computing device or set of devices that is capable ofcommunicating command-and-control messages to accessories (e.g., asdescribed in above-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/614,914) andpresenting a user interface to allow a user to indicate desiredoperations on the accessories. In some embodiments, controller 102 canbe implemented using multiple discrete devices. For example, there canbe a base station that communicates with accessories and that can beinstalled in a fixed location in environment 100, and one or more mobileremote-control stations (e.g., a handheld or wearable device such as amobile phone, tablet computer, smart watch, eyeglasses, etc.) thatprovide a user interface and communicate with the base station to effectcontrol over accessories. In some embodiments, the base station canfunction as a coordinator or proxy as described in above-referenced U.S.application Ser. No. 14/725,891.

Any type of accessory device can be controlled. Examples of accessorydevices include door lock 104, garage door system 106, light fixture108, security camera 110, and thermostat 112. In some instances,controller 102 can communicate directly with an accessory; for instance,controller 102 is shown communicating directly with door lock 104 andgarage door system 106. In other instances, controller 102 cancommunicate via an intermediary. For instance, controller 102 is showncommunicating via a wireless network access point 114 with accessories108, 110, 112 that are on a wireless network provided by access point114. As noted above, in some embodiments, controller 102 can include abase station, and base station functionality can be integrated intoaccess point 114 or into one of the accessories that is to be controlled(e.g., thermostat 112). In some embodiments, an intermediary canfunction as a proxy or coordinator as described in above-referenced U.S.application Ser. No. 14/725,891.

Various communication transports and combinations of transports can beused, and different transports can be used with different devices. Forexample, some wireless transports such as the Bluetooth® Classic orBluetooth® Smart communication protocol and standards promulgated by theBluetooth SIG (referred to herein as “Bluetooth” and “Bluetooth LE”) cansupport direct point-to-point communication between devices within alimited range. Other wireless transports such as a wireless networkcomplying with Wi-Fi® networking standards and protocols promulgated bythe Wi-Fi Alliance (referred to herein as a “Wi-Fi network”) can definea wireless network with a central access point that can facilitatecommunications between different devices on the network. Further, whilewireless communication transports are shown, wired transports can alsobe provided for some or all of the accessories. For example, light bulb108 can be connected to access point 114 by a wired connection, andcontroller 102 can communicate with light bulb 108 by sending messageswirelessly to access point 114, which can deliver the messages to lightbulb 108 via the wired connection. Other combinations of wired andwireless communication are also possible.

Further, while one controller 102 is shown, a home (or other)environment can have multiple associated controller devices. Forexample, each person who lives in the home may have his or her ownportable device (or devices) that can act as a controller for some orall of accessories 104-112. Different controller devices can beconfigured to communicate with different subsets of the accessories; forexample, a child's controller might be blocked from modifying settingson thermostat 112, while a parent's controller device is permitted tomodify the settings. Such permissions or privileged can be configuredand controlled, for example, using techniques described inabove-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,891 and U.S.application Ser. No. 14/725,912.

In some embodiments, a uniform accessory protocol can facilitatecommunication by a controller 102 with one or more accessories 104-112.The uniform accessory protocol can provide a simple and extensibleframework that models an accessory as a collection of services, witheach service being defined as a set of characteristics, each of whichhas a defined value at any given time. Various characteristics canrepresent various aspects of the accessory's state. For example, in thecase of thermostat 112, characteristics can include power (on or off),current temperature, and target temperature. In some embodiments,message formats may be transport-dependent while conforming to the sameaccessory model. An accessory can provide an “attribute database” thatidentifies the services and characteristics that the accessory exposesto controllers. A controller can read the attribute database (or aportion thereof) from an accessory and use the attribute database todetermine how to interact with the accessory. Examples of an accessorymodel based on services and characteristics are described inabove-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/614,914.

The uniform accessory protocol can further define message formats forcontroller 102 to send command-and-control messages (requests) toaccessory 112 (or other accessories) and for accessory 112 to sendresponse messages to controller 102. The command-and-control messagescan allow controller 102 to interrogate the current state of accessorycharacteristics (e.g., by sending a read request) and in some instancesto modify the characteristics (e.g., sending a request to write to thepower characteristic can result in turning an accessory off or on).Accordingly, any type of accessory, regardless of function ormanufacturer, can be controlled by sending appropriate messages. Themessage format can be the same across accessories of disparate types.Examples of message formats are described in above-referenced U.S.application Ser. No. 14/614,914.

The uniform accessory protocol can further provide notificationmechanisms that allow accessory 112 (or other accessories) toselectively notify controller 102 in the event of a state change.Multiple mechanisms can be implemented, and controller 102 can register,or subscribe, for the most appropriate notification mechanism for agiven purpose. Examples of notification mechanisms are described inabove-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/614,914.

In some embodiments, communication with a given accessory can be limitedto controllers that have received authorization. For instance, theuniform accessory protocol can specify one or more mechanisms (includingmechanisms referred to herein as “pair setup” and “pair add”) forestablishing a “pairing” (also referred to herein as a “local pairing”)between controller 102 and a given accessory (e.g., door lock accessory104) under circumstances that provide a high degree of confidence thatthe user intends for controller 102 to be able to control accessory 104.Pair setup can include an out-of-band information exchange (e.g., theuser can enter a numerical or alphanumeric PIN or passcode provided byaccessory 104 into an interface provided by controller 102) to establisha shared secret. This shared secret can be used to support secureexchange of “long-term” public keys between controller 102 and accessory104, and each device can store the long-term public key received fromthe other, so that an established pairing can be persistent. After alocal pairing is established, controller 102 is considered authorized,and thereafter, controller 102 and accessory 104 can go in and out ofcommunication as desired without losing the established pairing. Whencontroller 102 attempts to communicate with or control accessory 104, a“pair verify” process specified by the uniform accessory protocol canfirst be performed to verify that an established local pairing exists(as would be the case, e.g., where controller 102 previously completedpair setup with accessory 104). The pair verify process can include eachdevice demonstrating that it is in possession of a long-term private keycorresponding to the long-term public key that was exchanged during pairsetup and can further include establishing a new shared secret orsession key to encrypt all communications during a “pair-verified”session, (also referred to herein as a verified session). During apair-verified session, a controller that has appropriate privileges canperform a “pair add” process to establish another pairing with theaccessory on behalf of another controller. Either device can end apair-verified session at any time simply by destroying or invalidatingits copy of the session key.

In some embodiments, multiple controllers can establish a local pairingwith the same accessory (e.g., by performing pair setup or by having apairing added by a controller that previously performed pair setup), andthe accessory can accept and respond to communications from any of itspaired controllers while rejecting or ignoring communications fromunpaired controllers. Examples of pair setup, pair add and pair verifyprocesses, as well as other examples of security-related operations, aredescribed in above-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/614,914. Insome embodiments of the present invention, additional “relay pairing”processes can be defined and used to allow controllers to communicatewith accessories via a relay service external to the local environment.Examples are described below.

In some embodiments, a controller can establish a pairing with multipleaccessories and can define an “environment model” representing theaccessories in relation to each other. The model can be as simple as alist of accessories in the environment (e.g., all accessories present ina user's home). Other implementations can allow the user to definegroupings of accessories based on location (e.g., accessories in aspecific room within the home, or accessories in a “zone,” which can bedefined as a grouping of rooms such as all bedrooms or all upstairsrooms), by usage (e.g., a “service group” of accessories the user wantsto use together or an “action set” that can automatically triggercertain accessory operations in response to detected events orconditions), and so on. The environment model can also represent variouscontrollers and/or users that are authorized (or have “permission”) toaccess various accessories. Where multiple controllers share access tothe same environment, the environment model can be shared among thecontrollers using synchronization operations. Examples of environmentmodels and synchronization operations are described in above-referencedU.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,912.

It will be appreciated that home environment 100 is illustrative andthat variations and modifications are possible. Embodiments of thepresent invention can be implemented in any environment where a userwishes to control one or more accessory devices using a controllerdevice, including but not limited to homes, cars or other vehicles,office buildings, campuses having multiple buildings (e.g., a universityor corporate campus), etc. A single controller can establish pairingswith any number of accessories and can selectively communicate withdifferent accessories at different times. Similarly, a single accessorycan be controlled by multiple controllers with which it has establishedpairings. Any function of an accessory can be controlled by modeling thefunction as a service having one or more characteristics and allowing acontroller to interact with (e.g., read, modify, receive updates) theservice and/or its characteristics. Accordingly, protocols andcommunication processes used in embodiments of the invention can beuniformly applied in any context with one or more controllers and one ormore accessories, regardless of accessory function or controller formfactor or specific interfaces.

In some embodiments, one or more controllers can establish a level ofprivilege (referred to herein as an “administrator” or “admin”privilege) with an accessory that permits controllers with the adminprivilege to determine whether other controllers should be grantedpermission to communicate command-and-control messages to the accessory.For example, an accessory can restrict the pair setup operationdescribed above to situations in which it does not have an establishedpairing with any controller; the first controller to perform (local)pair setup is granted admin privilege automatically. Thereafter, theaccessory can refuse to permit additional pairings to be established,except by a controller that has admin privilege (such controllers alsohave an established pairing). The admin controller can add othercontrollers as authorized to use the accessory, e.g., using a pair addprocess. For instance, separately from any communication with theaccessory, the admin controller can obtain a long term public key for asecond controller. The admin controller can establish a verified session(also referred to as a “pair-verified session”) with the accessory usingthe long term public keys exchanged during pair setup. The verifiedsession can have a session key, and all communication within theverified session can be encrypted using the session key. Within theverified session, the admin controller can perform a pair add operationwith the accessory to establish a pairing between the accessory and thesecond controller. The pair add operation can include providing the longterm public key for the second controller to the accessory and receivingin exchange a second long term public key for the accessory (which mightor might not be the same key received when the first controllerestablished its pairing). The admin controller can communicate thesecond long term public key for the accessory to the second controller.This process can establish a local pairing between the second controllerand the accessory; thereafter, the second controller can establish itsown verified session to send command-and-control messages to theaccessory. The first controller can repeat the pair add process toestablish local pairings between the accessory and any number ofcontrollers. As described below, a separate processor can be used by anadmin controller to establish a relay pairing on behalf of anothercontroller.

In some instances, the first controller to pair can instruct theaccessory to grant an administrator (or “admin”) privilege to the secondcontroller, e.g., during the pair add process. Granting the adminprivilege can allow the second controller to perform pair add operationsto add additional controllers if desired, and depending onimplementation, the second controller might or might not be able togrant admin privilege to the additional controllers. The admin privilegecan be automatically assigned to the first controller that establishes apairing with a brand-new accessory (or with an accessory that has noestablished pairings). The use of an admin privilege can help deviceowners to regulate which controllers can obtain access to a particularaccessory.

FIG. 2 shows a network configuration 200 according to an embodiment ofthe present invention. Configuration 200 allows controllers 202 tocommunicate with accessories 204 located in local environment 206 (e.g.,a home environment such as environment 100 described above). Eachcontroller 202 can be an electronic device owned and/or operated by auser who frequents environment 206 (e.g., a resident of a home or aregular visitor to the home). Controllers 202 can each be similar tocontroller 102 of FIG. 1, and accessories 204 can be similar to variousaccessories shown in FIG. 1.

Accessories 204 can each communicate with an access point 210 that canbe located in local environment 206. Access point 210 can provide alocal area network (LAN) to which accessories 204 and controllers 202(when present in local environment 206) can connect. Any type of LANtechnology can be used, including Wi-Fi networks or other wireless LANtechnologies. Thus, access point 210 can facilitate communicationbetween accessories 204 and controllers 202 within local environment206. In some embodiments, a controller (e.g., controller 202(1)) that ispresent in local environment 206 can communicate directly with anaccessory (e.g., accessory 204(1)). Bluetooth communication, ad hocwireless networking, or other point-to-point communication technologiescan be used as desired.

In some instances, an accessory might not communicate directly withaccess point 210 or with controllers 202. For example, accessory 204(3)can be connected to a proxy 212, and controllers 202 and/or access point210 can communicate with accessory 204(3) via proxy 212. In variousembodiments, proxy 212 can provide relaying of messages to and fromaccessory 204(3). Proxy 212 can implement communication securitymeasures and/or protocol translation, and a single proxy 212 caninterface to one or more accessories 204. In some embodiments, proxy 212can be an “intelligent” device that can coordinate operations amongmultiple controllers and/or accessories and is not limited to passivelyrelaying messages. Specific examples of proxy devices that can beimplemented as proxy 212 (including devices referred to variously asbridges, tunnels, and coordinators) are described in above-referencedU.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,891.

In some embodiments, accessories 204 and controllers 202 that arepresent in local environment 206 can communicate using a local areanetwork (LAN), such as a Wi-Fi network and/or a point-to-pointcommunication medium such as Bluetooth LE. It is to be understood thatother communication transports and protocols can be used. In someembodiments, controllers 202 and accessories 204 (and proxy 212 ifpresent) can support a uniform accessory protocol as described abovethat can be implemented using both Wi-Fi and Bluetooth LE as transports.

In the example of FIG. 2, controller 202(1) is currently located inlocal environment 206 with accessories 204 and coordinator 210. Forexample, controller 202(1) can be on the same LAN as accessories 204.Controllers 202(2) and 202(3) are currently located outside localenvironment 206 but are connected to a communication network 208 (e.g.,the Internet); such controllers are said to be “remote” from accessories204. It is to be understood that controllers 202 can be mobile devicesthat are sometimes within local environment 206 and sometimes outsidelocal environment 206. Accessories 204 need not be mobile and need notbe connected to communication network 208. In some embodiments, accesspoint 210 can be connected to communication network 208 (e.g., accesspoint 210 can be implemented as a conventional Wi-Fi access point orbase station) and can permit remote access to accessories 204 by remotecontrollers 202(2) and 202(3).

However, it may not be desirable to configure each of accessories 204 asa wide-area network device that can be found and communicated with byany device able to connect to communication network 208. For instance,if communication network 208 is the Internet, a vast number of devices,including devices owned by anyone anywhere in the world, may be able tolocate accessories 204 and attempt operations for which they are notauthorized. Thus, to more selectively allow controllers 202 tocommunicate with accessories 204 via network 208, it may be useful toemploy a relay service 220.

According to various embodiments of the present invention, relay service220 can facilitate communication between controllers 202 (in particularremote controllers 202(2), 202(3)) and accessories 204 via communicationnetwork 208. For example, relay service 220 can establish a persistentconnection to accessory 204(1), in which accessory 204(1) is identifiedby a persistent accessory alias (also referred to as an “accessory relayalias,” or “accessory RA”) that is assigned by relay service 220 andknown to controllers 202 (but presumably not to other devices that arenot authorized to access accessories 204). Controller 202(2) can send arequest to relay service 220 to deliver a message to accessory 204(1);the request can include the message content, the accessory aliasassigned to accessory 204(1) by relay service 220, and additionalinformation (e.g., an access token as described below) usable by relayservice 220 to verify that controller 202(2) is authorized tocommunicate with accessory 204(1). Relay service 220 can deliver themessage to accessory 204(1). Response messages from accessory 204(1) canbe delivered to controller 202(2) in a similar manner, using apersistent operator alias (also referred to as an “operator relayalias,” or “operator RA”) that is assigned to controller 202(2) by relayservice 220 and known to accessory 204(1) but presumably not to devicesthat are not authorized to use relay service 220 to communicate withcontroller 202(2). The message content exchanged between controller202(2) and accessory 204(1) via relay service 220 can conform to auniform accessory protocol as described above, and message content canbe opaque to relay service 220. Accordingly, controller 202(2) andaccessory 204(1) can communicate via relay service 220 to establish apair-verified session (as defined above) and can encrypt message contentsuch that the message content is not readable by relay service 220 orany other intermediary through which the message content may pass. Inthis manner, relay service 220 can provide a secure end-to-endcommunication path (indicated by dashed line 222) between controller202(2) and accessory 204(1) (or between any controller 202 and anyaccessory 204).

In some embodiments, controllers 202 can be configured to communicatewith accessories 204 without using relay server 220 when possible. Forexample, when controller 202(2) determines that it should send a messageto accessory 204(1) (e.g., based on user input or a receivednotification as described below), a communication daemon or otherprocess executing in controller 202(2) can determine whether “localaccess” (or a “local channel”) to accessory 204(1) is currentlyavailable. For instance, controller 202(2) can actively or passivelyscan for the presence of accessory 204(1) on a local network orpoint-to-point communication technology; if accessory 204(1) isdetected, then local access is possible. If accessory 204(1) is notdetected, then local access is not available and controller 202(2) cancommunicate with relay service 220 instead. The determination whether touse local access or relay service 220 can be transparent to the user andcan be made each time a communication channel to the accessory is to beestablished. Thus, a user who wants to interact with accessory 204(1)using controller 202(2) can simply do so without worrying about whetherto use local access or remote access via relay service 220.

It will be appreciated that network configuration 200 is illustrativeand that variations and modifications are possible. Any number ofcontrollers and any number of accessories can be included in a networkconfiguration. In some embodiments, the network configuration caninclude one or more proxies (e.g., bridges, tunnels, coordinators asdescribed in above-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,912).Some or all of accessories 204 may be accessible only within the localenvironment. Further, as described below, different controllers 202 mayhave different levels of permission in regard to accessing accessories204; for instance, remote access via network 208 may be permitted forsome controllers 202 but not for other controllers 202.

Example Relay Service

FIG. 3 shows a simplified block diagram of a relay service 300 accordingto an embodiment of the present invention. Relay service 300 can be animplementation of relay service 220 of FIG. 2 and can relay messagesbetween a controller 302 (e.g., any of controllers 202 of FIG. 2) and anaccessory 304 (e.g., any of accessories 204 of FIG. 2).

Relay service 300 can include a certificate server 310, an identityserver 320, an accessory courier server 330, a controller courier server340, a message passing server 350, a pass server 360, a reporting server370, and a bag server 380. Each server can be implemented as a singleserver or server farm using conventional server hardware (e.g.,interconnected blade servers), and the same or different server hardwarecan be used to implement different servers.

Certificate server 310 can be used to generate identity tokens andpublic key infrastructure (PKI) certificates for endpoint devices(including accessory 304 and/or controller 302) that use relay service300. In operation, certificate server 310 can implement a certificateauthority capable of generating PKI certificates upon request (e.g.,using standard certificate-generating algorithms) and validating PKIcertificates upon request. Certificate server 310 can also generate adevice identity token for an endpoint device and associate the deviceidentity token with the PKI certificate. The device identity token canbe, for example, a randomly generated universally unique identifier(UUID). In some embodiments, the device identity token is generatedaccording to a scheme that ensures that the device identity tokenprovides no information as to the nature, capabilities, and/or physicallocation of the device to which it is assigned. Once a device identitytoken and a PKI certificate have been assigned to an endpoint device,the endpoint device is said to be “activated.” An activated device cansubsequently authenticate itself to relay service 300 by presenting itsdevice identity token and PKI certificate. Certificate server 310 canstore a certificate repository 312 including valid UUIDs and associatedPKI certificates and can use certificate repository 312 to facilitateauthentication of an endpoint device. Examples of operation ofcertificate server 310 are described below.

Identity server 320 can be used to generate “access” tokens that allowspecific controllers to communicate with specific accessories. Asdescribed below, when a controller (e.g., controller 302) and anaccessory (e.g., accessory 304) mutually request to be paired within thecontext of relay service 300 (referred to as establishing a “relaypairing,” which can be distinct from a local pairing), identity server320 can generate a unique access token that is associated with an“operator relay alias” (also referred to as an “operator alias” or“operator RA”) of controller 302 and with an “accessory relay alias”(also referred to as an “accessory alias” or “accessory RA”) ofaccessory 304. The operator RA and accessory RA can be aliasesarbitrarily assigned by relay service 300; examples are described below.Access tokens generated by identity server 320 can be securely deliveredto the particular accessory 304 and controller 302 that requested arelay pairing. Thereafter, when controller 302 sends a relay request torelay service 300 to relay a message to accessory 304 (or vice versa),controller 302 (or accessory 304) can provide the corresponding accesstoken to relay service 300 together with the message content, theoperator RA, and the accessory RA. Identity server 320 can maintain atoken repository 322 that associates a combination of accessory RA andoperator RA with an access token, thus allowing identity server 320 tovalidate the access token. Relay service 300 can decline to relay amessage if a valid access token is not provided. Examples of operationof identity server 320 are described below.

Accessory courier server 330 can maintain a persistent connection (e.g.,a socket) to endpoint accessory devices (e.g., accessory 304) that havebeen registered with relay service 300 (e.g., via certificate server 310as described below). Through this connection, accessory courier server330 can deliver messages received from a controller (e.g., controller302) by relay service 300 to accessory 304 and can receive relayrequests from accessory 304 that include messages to be delivered tocontroller 302 (or to another controller, as specified by accessory304). For instance, accessory courier service 330 can maintain a mapping332 of accessory RAs to active sockets and can deliver messages toaccessory 304 or pass messages received from accessory 304 based on theaccessory RA included with the message. Examples of operation ofaccessory courier server 330 are described below. As will becomeapparent, accessory courier server 330 can be agnostic as to what type(e.g., manufacturer and/or functionality) of accessory 304 iscommunicating, where accessory 304 is physically located, whatcontroller 302 (or user) is communicating with accessory 304, or whatinformation is being communicated between accessory 304 and controller302.

Controller courier server 340 can establish persistent connections toendpoint controller devices (e.g., controller 302) that have beenregistered with relay service 300. In some embodiments, controllercourier server 340 can leverage an existing infrastructure forcommunicating messages between mobile devices of different users and/orpushing notifications to a user's mobile device(s), such as theinfrastructure supporting the iMessage® service and/or push notificationservices for mobile devices provided by Apple Inc., assignee of thepresent application. In some embodiments, controller courier server 340can maintain a mapping 342 of operator RAs associated with a particularuser to device IDs that can be associated with specific controllerdevices owned or operated by the user. Examples of operation ofcontroller courier server 340 are described below. As will becomeapparent, controller courier server 340 can be agnostic as to theidentity or functionality of accessory 304 with which controller 302 iscommunicating or what information is being communicated betweencontroller 302 and accessory 304.

Message passing server 350 can be implemented using various gateways andthe like and can operate to direct messages between accessory courierserver 330 and controller courier server 340. For example, messagepassing server 350 can direct messages received from controller 302 viacontroller courier server 340 to accessory courier server 330 fordelivery to accessory 304; passing of messages in the reverse directioncan also be supported. In some embodiments, message passing server 350can also facilitate passing of messages between any servers included inrelay service 300, e.g., between accessory courier server 330 andcertificate server 310, and so on. Examples of operation of messagepassing server 350 are described below.

Pass server 360 can be used to support a “pass” service that allowsrelay service 300 to block access by anomalous or suspect accessories.For example, in order to establish a connection with accessory courierserver 330, accessory 304 (or any accessory) may be required to presenta pass obtained from pass server 360. In some embodiments, accessory 304can request a pass by providing accessory-identifying information (e.g.,manufacturer and model information) to pass server 360. Pass server 360can determine whether the accessory-identifying information is includedin a current “blacklist” 362 of anomalous accessories that have beentemporarily or permanently blocked from using relay service 300;examples of creating and updating blacklist 362 are described below. Ifaccessory 304 is not included in blacklist 362, pass server 360 cangenerate a pass for accessory 304. The pass can include a timestamp(e.g., with five or ten minute granularity or the like) and a codeusable by accessory courier server 306 to verify that the pass wasissued by pass server 360. The pass need not include any informationspecific to accessory 304, and pass server 360 can generate identicalpasses in response to multiple requests from different accessories. Theaccessory can present the pass to accessory courier server 330. In thisexample, pass server 360 can receive identifying information about theaccessory (e.g., manufacturer and model information may indicate whattype of accessory it is) but does not need to retain the identifyinginformation or associate it with the accessory RA used elsewhere withinrelay service 300, and the pass generated by pass server 360 need notcontain any accessory-identifying information. In some embodiments, passserver 360 can communicate to accessory courier server 330, e.g., toprovide a currently valid timestamp. Examples of operation of passserver 360 are described below.

Reporting server 370 can manage a reporting and diagnostic process thatallows for privacy-protected collection of information about accessoriesthat may be behaving anomalously (e.g., generating excessive traffic onrelay service 300). For example, as described below, while investigatinganomalous activity, reporting server 370 can receive reports fromcontroller devices that provide accessory-identifying informationassociated with an investigation identifier (or “investigation ID”)assigned by an operator of relay service 300. The reports can beanonymous in that the particular operator RA and/or accessory RA are notprovided. Based on the received reports, reporting server 370 canidentify accessory types correlated with anomalous behavior (e.g., agarage door opener made by a particular manufacturer) and can initiatefollow-up action, such as alerting the manufacturer to the anomalousbehavior and/or adding the anomalous accessory type to blacklist 362until the underlying issue can be resolved. Examples of operation ofreporting server 370 are described below.

Bag server 380 can be used to provide accessory 304 and controller 302with addressing information usable to enable communication with variousservers of relay service 300, including, e.g., controller courier server340 and/or accessory courier server 330. The addressing information caninclude, e.g., a uniform resource locator (“URL”) or information usableto construct a URL for various servers of relay service 300. Forexample, a URL can be constructed using a base host name and a hostinstance identifier, either or both of which can be provided by bagserver 380. The addressing information can be provided in the form of a“bag” (e.g., a data structure containing various fields of addressinginformation for one or more servers of relay service 300) by bag server380 in response to a request, e.g., from controller 302 (which canreceive “Bag-c” as shown in FIG. 3) or accessory 304 (which can receive“Bag-a” as shown in FIG. 3). In some embodiments, controller 302 oraccessory 304 can cache a received bag and continue using the baginformation across multiple connections to the server. In someembodiments, the bag can include expiration information (e.g., time tolive), and after the expiration of the bag, a controller or accessorycan retrieve a new bag from bag server 380. The new bag may contain thesame information or different information. While bag server 380 and theuse of bags to provide addressing information are not required, use of abag or similar mechanism to provide addressing information for variousservers of relay service 300 can allow the operator of relay service 300to dynamically reallocate resources (e.g., for load balancing amongmultiple instances of accessory courier server 330 or controller courierserver 340 and/or for security purposes).

In operation, the various servers of relay service 300 can communicatewith each other and with controllers and accessories using a transportprotocol that provides transport layer security. For example,communication can be enabled using HTTPS/IP (hypertext transportprotocol with Secure Socket Layer (SSL) implemented on an InternetProtocol stack, a well-known transport protocol) or HTTP2 with TransportLayer Security (TLS). Any or all messages exchanged between servers ofrelay service 300 can be digitally signed by the sending server andvalidated by the receiving server. Messages exchanged between accessory304 and controller 302 via relay service 300 can have additionalsecurity at the message level. For example, as described above, anaccessory and controller can communicate using a uniform accessoryprotocol that provides security through a pair-verified session that hasan associated session key. Via relay service 300, controller 302 andaccessory 304 can establish a pair-verified session according to theuniform accessory protocol, thereby establishing a session key knownonly to controller 302 and accessory 304. The content of messages withinthe pair-verified session can be encrypted with the session key, therebyrendering message content opaque to relay service 300 (and any otherintermediary through which the message content may pass, such as variousInternet gateways, routers, and so on). This can provide a reliablelevel of privacy protection for users.

Communication between accessory 304 and accessory courier server 330 canuse a different protocol from communication between controller 302 andcontroller courier server 340. For example, accessory 304 can sendcommunications to accessory courier server 330 as HTTP requests (e.g.,POST or GET requests to appropriate URLs defined at accessory courierserver 340) and can receive communications as HTTP responses. At thesame time, controller courier server 340 can use a messaging protocol(e.g., similar to SMTP or other email protocols) with header fieldsidentifying the message sender and intended recipient, and a messagebody containing content to be delivered to the intended recipient. Insome embodiments, message passing server 350 can convert communicationsbetween accessory courier server 330 and controller courier server 340into appropriate formats.

It should also be noted that relay service 300 can be implemented tolimit the distribution or accessibility of device-identifyinginformation. For example, as described below, relay service 300 need notretain any information identifying accessory type or capabilities ofaccessory 304; instead, relay service 300 can simply retain enoughinformation to verify that accessory 304 is an authorized endpointdevice. The burden can be placed on accessory 304 to maintain aconnection to relay service 300, and apart from the specific connection,relay service 300 does not need to know how to deliver communications toaccessory 304. Operator relay aliases and accessory relay aliases usedby relay service 300 can be assigned using random processes or otherprocesses such that the aliases are not usable by third parties toassociate messages exchanged through relay service 300 with a specificreal-world controller or accessory. Even within relay service 300, itmight not be possible to make such associations reliably. Thus, userprivacy can be respected while still providing the convenience of beingable to communicate with an accessory from anywhere in the world.

It will be appreciated that relay service 300 is illustrative and thatvariations and modifications are possible. Any number and combination ofservers can be used to implement the various operations described hereinas being performed by relay service 300 or components thereof. In someembodiments, operations described as being performed by differentservers can be implemented using different software modules executing onthe same server hardware. Further, not all servers and operationsdescribed herein are required; for instance, pass server 360, reportingserver 370, and/or bag server 380 can be omitted. User privacy can beprotected by limiting the information available to the various servers,while still retaining the ability of the servers to delivercommunication between authorized devices and to recognize and blockunauthorized communications.

Relay Setup Example

In some embodiments, relay service 300 can be used to relay messagesbetween controller 302 and accessory 304 only after controller 302 andaccessory 304 are established as endpoint devices that are authorized tocommunicate with each other. This process can be referred to as settingup a relay pairing and can include multiple stages. In a first stage,accessory 304 can be “activated” (e.g., obtaining authorizationcredentials that will allow accessory 304 to access relay service 300).In a second stage, accessory 304 and controller 302 can obtain andexchange aliases (also referred to as “relay aliases”) assigned by relayservice 300 for use in relaying messages between them. In a third stage,accessory 304 and controller 302 can establish a “relay pairing.” Thiscan be different from establishing a local pairing according to theuniform accessory protocol (e.g., using local pair setup and pair addprocesses described above). Examples of relay setup processes will nowbe described.

FIG. 4 shows a simplified flow diagram of an accessory activationprocess 400 according to an embodiment of the present invention. Process400 can be implemented, e.g., using relay service 300 of FIG. 3. In thisexample, it is assumed that process 400 is performed at a time whencontroller 302 has local access to accessory 304 (e.g., as describedabove with reference to FIG. 2). It is also assumed that controller 302has already established a local pairing with regard to accessory 304according to a uniform accessory protocol as described above. (In someembodiments, local pairing is not required, but requiring local pairingas a precondition of accessory activation may provide useful securityfeatures for accessories.)

At blocks 402 and 404, accessory 304 and controller 302 can establishcommunication via a local channel. Communication can be establishedaccording to the uniform accessory protocol as described above. Forexample, establishing communication at blocks 402 and 404 can includeestablishing a pair-verified session between accessory 304 andcontroller 302.

At block 406, controller 302 can determine that accessory 304 should beactivated on the relay service. For example, as noted above, accessory304 can present to controller 302 an accessory model including acollection of services. In some embodiments, one of these services canbe a “remote relay access” service. The presence of the remote relayaccess service in the accessory model can indicate to controller 302that the accessory supports remote access via relay service 300. (It isnot required that all accessories in a given environment support remoteaccess via relay service 300 or any other form of remote access.) Theremote relay access service can include various characteristics, one ofwhich can have a Boolean value indicating whether the accessory has beenactivated, and block 406 can include reading this characteristic. Insome embodiments, the determination at block 406 can also be based onuser input. For instance, after establishing a pairing with accessory304, controller 302 can present a prompt to the user to indicate whetheraccessory 304 should be configured for remote access via relay service300; depending on the user's response, controller 302 can eithercontinue or terminate process 400. Other decision criteria may also beused.

At block 407, controller 302 can obtain a controller bag from bag server380. In some embodiments, the controller bag can include addressinginformation for some or all of the servers of relay service 300. Forexample, the controller bag can include addressing information for anyor all of certificate server 310, identity server 320, controllercourier server 340, and reporting server 370. In some embodiments, thecontroller bag can also include a URL to be used by accessory 304 toobtain its own bag from bag server 380. In some embodiments, controller302 can obtain a controller bag during an initial configuration processor the first time it determines that an accessory should be activated onrelay service 300; thereafter controller 302 can determine whether andwhen to obtain a new controller bag based on the expiration informationin the previously obtained controller bag.

At blocks 408 and 410, controller 302 can authenticate itself tocertificate server 310. It is assumed that controller 302 has alreadyestablished an identity with certificate server 310; for instance, aspart of the initial configuration of controller 302, controller 302 mayhave obtained a PKI certificate and device identity token (e.g., a UUIDas described above) for itself from certificate server 310 (or fromanother source). In some embodiments, controller 302 can be provisionedwith a PKI certificate and/or device identity token during manufacture.In some embodiments, controller 302 can obtain an initial controller bagfrom bag server 380 prior to establishing an identity with certificateserver 310, and controller 302 can determine a URL for certificateserver 310 based on addressing information in the controller bag.Certificate server 310 can perform standard certificate-validationtechniques, such as receiving and validating a PKI certificate fromcontroller 302, then obtaining a signed digital challenge fromcontroller 302 and using the validated PKI certificate to verify thesignature. Other authentication techniques can also be used. In someembodiments, authentication at blocks 408, 410 can be bidirectional;that is, controller 302 can also authenticate certificate server 310before proceeding.

Having authenticated controller 302, at blocks 412, 414, and 416,controller 302 can perform a second authentication operation withcertificate server 310 on behalf of accessory 304. For example,accessory 304 can be provisioned during manufacture with a digitalsecurity certificate (which can be issued, e.g., through a licensingprogram offered by a provider of relay service 300, such as the Made foriPhone (MFi) licensing program offered by Apple Inc.). Blocks 412, 414,and 416 can include controller 302 retrieving the digital securitycertificate from accessory 304 (via the local channel), forwarding thedigital security certificate to certificate server 310 for validation,receiving a digital challenge from certificate server 310, forwardingthe digital challenge to accessory 304 (via the local channel) forsignature, receiving a response from accessory 304 (via the localchannel), and forwarding the response to certificate server 310. In someembodiments, the communication between accessory 304 and controller 302can be performed by reading from and/or writing to characteristics ofthe accessory's remote relay access service (or another accessoryservice depending on implementation). Certificate server 310 canvalidate the digital security certificate (e.g., by communicating withthe certificate authority that issued it or by using an establishedtrust chain) and use the validated certificate to verify the signeddigital challenge produced by accessory 304.

Assuming authentication of accessory 304 succeeds, at block 420,certificate server 310 can generate a new PKI certificate and anassociated device identity token (e.g., UUID) for accessory 304. The newPKI certificate and/or device identity token can be generated usingrandom or pseudorandom processes or the like, such that the PKIcertificate and/or device identity token are not usable to reconstructany accessory-identifying information (e.g., manufacturer, accessorytype, accessory functionality, or accessory location) that may have beenincluded (explicitly or implicitly) in the original digital securitycertificate with which accessory 304 is provisioned during manufacture.For example, the digital security certificate used to authenticate theaccessory at blocks 412, 414, 416 may be usable to determine amanufacture, accessory type, or other information about what accessory304 is and/or what it can do. The PKI certificate and device identitytoken (e.g., UUID) issued by certificate server 310 need not have anycorrelation with any accessory attribute. In some embodiments,certificate server 310 can persistently store the PKI certificate andUUID (or other device identity token) without also retaining theaccessory's digital security certificate or any information obtainedtherefrom. In some embodiments, the PKI certificate generated bycertificate server 310 can include an encoded representation ofaccessory-identifying information extracted from the accessory's digitalsecurity certificate (e.g., a hash of the manufacturer and model). Suchinformation can be encoded in a way that is difficult or impossible forthird parties to decode, e.g., using a hash function or the like. Thedevice identity token can be any identifier that is unique across thenamespace of certificate server 310 and can be uncorrelated with anyaccessory-identifying information (e.g., manufacturer or model).

At block 422, certificate server 310 can send the new PKI certificateand UUID (or other device identity token) to controller 302. Controller302 can receive the new PKI certificate and UUID at block 424 andprovide them to accessory 304 at block 426, e.g., by writing to anappropriate characteristic of the accessory's remote relay accessservice. At block 428, accessory 304 can receive and persistently storeits new PKI certificate and UUID. As described below, this informationcan be used for authentication when accessory 304 subsequently connectsto relay service 300. Controller 302 does not need to store the PKIcertificate or UUID.

It will be appreciated that process 400 is illustrative and thatvariations and modifications are possible. Steps described as sequentialmay be executed in parallel, order of steps may be varied, and steps maybe modified, combined, added or omitted. For instance, authentication ofthe controller and the accessory to certificate server 310 can occur inparallel or in a different order. In some embodiments, the PKIcertificate generated during process 400 can have an expiration date andcan be short-lived or long-lived as desired. Further, it is not requiredthat certificate server 310 maintain a certificate repository, as otherservers can validate the signature of certificate server 310. Differentauthentication techniques can be used in addition to or instead ofcertificate and signature validation, and the authentication informationgenerated by certificate server 310 for accessory 304 is not limited toPKI certificates and UUIDs (or other device identifying tokens).

Upon completion of process 400, accessory 304 can be said to be“activated,” that is, accessory 304 has an established identity (e.g.,PKI certificate and UUID) that it can use to connect to relay service300. Accordingly, relay pairing setup can proceed to the next stage, inwhich accessory 304 and controller 302 can obtain and exchangeidentifiers assigned by relay service 300 for use in relaying messagesbetween them.

FIG. 5 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process 500 by which acontroller (e.g., controller 302) can obtain an operator relay aliasthat can be used for relaying messages to and from accessories accordingto an embodiment of the present invention. In embodiments describedherein, the relay alias is associated with an “operator” of controller302, who can be the user to whom controller 302 belongs, rather thanwith a specific controller device. This allows multiple controllerdevices belonging to the same user to have the same accessory access viarelay server 300 without having to establish a separate relay pairingfor each controller device. In other embodiments, a relay alias can beassigned to a specific controller device rather than the operator.

At block 502 of process 500, controller 302 can send a request toidentity server 320 to establish an operator relay alias (or “operatorRA”). This operator RA can be associated with a user of controller 302.For example, a user of controller 302 can have an account with a serviceprovider of relay service 300 that can be used to access not only relayservice 300 but also other network-based services from the same serviceprovider, such as data storage and/or streaming services, inter-devicecommunication services, software and/or firmware management services,etc. One example of a user account can be a user account with the iCloudservice of Apple Inc. The user can link controller 302 to the user'saccount, e.g., by providing the username and password (or other accesscredentials) to controller 302, which can present the credentials torelay service 300 (e.g., to identity server 320) at block 502.

At block 504, identity server 320 can receive the request for anoperator RA. In some embodiments, identity server 320 can performvarious validation operations to validate the request, e.g., verifyingthe user account credentials provided by controller 302, performing acertificate-based authentication operation with controller 302 (e.g.,using certificate server 310), etc. Assuming the request is valid, atblock 506, identity server 320 can either generate or retrieve anoperator RA for controller 302. For example, if this is the first timethat the user has connected a controller to relay service 300, identityserver 320 can generate a new operator RA and associate the operator RAwith the user account. If the user has previously connected anothercontroller to relay service 300, the user account may already beassociated with an operator RA, and processing at block 506 can includeretrieving the operator RA (e.g., by a lookup operation, querying adatabase, or the like). It should be noted that the operator RA can beused specifically for relaying messages between the user's controller(s)and various accessories; if desired, other aliases can be independentlygenerated for other activities and operations that may be connected withthe user's account. Further, the operator RA can be generated usingrandom or pseudorandom processes or the like, such that the operator RAis not correlated with the account credentials or any other identifyinginformation about the user, the account, or the particular controllerused to generate the operator RA. In some embodiments, relay service 300may internally be able to associate the operator RA with a user accountor controller device (e.g., using a table maintained by identity server320 or by using a reversible hash algorithm or the like to generateoperator RAs), but the association need not be desirable from theoperator RA without additional information.

At block 508, identity server 320 can send the generated or retrievedoperator RA to controller 302. At block 510, controller 302 can receiveand persistently store the operator RA. In some embodiments, acontroller can use the same operator RA for all relay-servicetransactions as described below, and a given controller may performprocess 500 once and store the resulting operator RA indefinitely.

It will be appreciated that process 500 is illustrative and thatvariations and modifications are possible. Steps described as sequentialmay be executed in parallel, order of steps may be varied, and steps maybe modified, combined, added or omitted. Process 500 can be performed atany time, independently of when other processes described herein areperformed. For instance, in some embodiments, an operator RA for relayservice 300 can be generated whenever a user establishes an account witha relevant service provider and can be automatically delivered to eachcontroller that the user associates with the account. Thus, for example,process 500 can be performed either before or after process 400described above. Further, in some embodiments, the operator RA can beassociated with a specific controller rather than just with a useraccount, so different controllers belonging to the same user can havedifferent operator RAs.

To enable relay service 300 to operate between controller 302 andaccessory 304, controller 302 needs to provide its operator RA toaccessory 304 and obtain an accessory relay alias (or “accessory RA”)for accessory 304. FIG. 6 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process600 for exchanging operator and accessory RAs according to an embodimentof the present invention. Process 600 can be performed in part, e.g., bycontroller 302 interacting with accessory 304, and in part, e.g., byaccessory 304 interacting with accessory courier server 330. It isassumed that process 600 is performed at a time when controller 302 haslocal access to accessory 304, so that communication between controller302 and accessory 304 can occur via a local channel without the use ofrelay service 300.

Process 600 can begin when controller 302 has an operator RA (e.g., as aresult of process 500) and accessory 304 has a PKI certificate and UUID(e.g., as a result of process 400). At block 602, controller 302 canprovide its operator RA, e.g., by writing to an appropriatecharacteristic (or characteristics) of the remote relay access service.In some embodiments, controller 302 can also provide a “bag URL” thatthe accessory can use to obtain an accessory bag from bag server 380,e.g., by writing to an appropriate characteristic (or characteristics)of the remote relay access service. In some embodiments, the URL for bagserver 380 can be determined from information in a controller bag heldby controller 302. At block 604, accessory 304 can receive andpersistently store the operator RA (and bag URL if provided). Assumingthe operator RA is received via a pair-verified session on a localchannel, accessory 304 can associate the operator RA with the controlleridentifier that was used to establish the pair-verified session on thelocal channel. While such association is not required, doing so canallow a controller that has established admin privileges for its localpairing with accessory 304 to have the same admin privileges whencommunicating via relay service 300. Further, associating an operator RAwith a local pairing can allow accessory 304 to restrict relay access tocontrollers that have established a local pairing.

At block 605, accessory 304 can obtain an accessory bag from bag server380, e.g., by sending a GET request to the bag URL provided bycontroller 302. In some embodiments, the accessory bag can includeaddressing information for various servers of relay service 300, e.g.,any or all of accessory courier server 330 and/or pass server 360. Insome embodiments, the accessory bag can include expiration information;subsequently to process 600, accessory 302 can determine whether andwhen to obtain a new accessory bag based on the expiration informationin the previously obtained accessory bag.

Having received an operator RA, accessory 304 can proceed to obtain anaccessory RA. For example, at block 606, accessory 304 can send arequest for an accessory RA to accessory courier server 330. In someembodiments, the request can include the PKI certificate and UUID (orother device identifying token) obtained via process 400 describedabove; alternatively, the PKI certificate and UUID can be sent in aseparate transaction. In some embodiments, accessory 304 can be requiredto present a pass to accessory courier server 330 in connection with therequest. Accessory 304 can obtain a pass from pass server 360, e.g., asdescribed below with reference to FIG. 12.

At block 608, accessory courier server 330 can receive the request. Atblock 610, accessory courier server 330 can validate the accessory's PKIcertificate. In some embodiments, accessory courier server 330 cancommunicate with certificate server 310 to validate the accessory's PKIcertificate; in other embodiments, courier server 330 can validate basedon the signature on the accessory's PKI certificate. At block 612,assuming the PKI certificate is validated, accessory courier server 330can generate an accessory RA for accessory 304. In some embodiments, theaccessory RA can be generated using random or pseudorandom processes orthe like, such that the accessory RA is not correlated with anyidentifying information about the accessory. In some embodiments, theaccessory RA can incorporate the UUID, e.g., in an encrypted data block,to allow relay service 300 to connect the accessory RA with the UUIDwithout also enabling third parties to do so. The accessory RA can begenerated such that it is unique across all currently valid accessoryRAs. At block 614, accessory courier server 330 can send the accessoryRA to the accessory, e.g., as a response to the request received atblock 608.

At block 616, accessory 304 can receive the accessory RA from accessorycourier server 330. Accessory 304 can persistently store the accessoryRA and use it for future connections to accessory courier server 330. Atblock 618, accessory 304 can send its accessory RA to controller 302.For example, controller 302 can include a request for the accessory RAat block 602 when it sends the operator RA to accessory 304, andaccessory 304 can send a response to the request at block 618. Othertechniques can also be used.

At block 620, controller 302 can receive and store the accessory RA. Insome embodiments, controller 302 can store the accessory RA inassociation with the accessory identifier that was used to establish thepair-verified session on the local channel, via which the accessory RAis received. This can allow controller 302 to access accessory 304interchangeably via either a local channel or relay service 300.

It will be appreciated that process 600 is illustrative and thatvariations and modifications are possible. Steps described as sequentialmay be executed in parallel, order of steps may be varied, and steps maybe modified, combined, added or omitted. A controller and accessory canobtain and exchange operator RA and accessory RA at any time and ineither order For instance, it should be noted that accessory 304 doesnot use the operator RA in obtaining its accessory RA during process600. Accordingly, it is possible for accessory 304 to obtain anaccessory RA at any time after receiving a PKI certificate and UUID.Having the accessory's request to accessory courier server 330 triggeredon receiving the operator RA from the controller can allow controller302 to exert more control over when or whether accessories requestaccessory RAs. In some embodiments, accessory 304 can use the sameaccessory RA for pairings with different controllers, and an accessorythat already has an accessory RA does not need to request another oneduring the process 600.

Upon completion of process 600, accessory 304 and controller 302 areeach in possession of an (accessory RA, operator RA) pair. Relay service300 has associated the accessory RA with accessory 304, at least to theextent that accessory courier server 330 can pass messages to accessory304 based on the accessory RA, and has associated the operator RA withcontroller 302, at least to the extent that controller courier server340 can pass messages to controller 302 based on the operator RA.

At this point, it is possible to establish an association between theaccessory RA and operator RA within relay service 300, such that relayservice 300 can begin to permit messages to be relayed between accessory304 and controller 302. This association is referred to herein as a“relay pairing,” and is to be understood as being distinct from localpairing established by operations such as pair setup and pair adddescribed above.

FIG. 7 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process 700 for establishinga relay pairing according to an embodiment of the present invention.Process 700 can be performed in part by controller 302 communicatingwith identity server 320, in part by controller 302 communicating withaccessory 304 via a local channel, and in part by accessory 304communicating with identity server 320 (which can occur via accessorycourier server 330). It is assumed that controller 302 and accessory 304each have the (accessory RA, operator RA) pair corresponding the twodevices, e.g., as a result of performing processes 400, 500, and 600.

In this example, at block 702, accessory 304 can send a pairing request(e.g., via accessory courier service 330, not shown) to identity server320. The pairing request can include the (accessory RA, operator RA)pair. At block 704, identity server 320 can receive the request. In someembodiments, controller 302 can instruct accessory 304 to send thepairing request in response to receiving the accessory RA at block 620of process 600 described above. At block 706, identity server 320 cangenerate a temporary pairing token to be associated with the pairingrequest. The temporary pairing token can include, for example, theoperator RA, the accessory RA, a timestamp indicating when the temporarypairing token was generated, and an expiration time (which can be, e.g.,10 minutes or 1 hour or the like after the generation time). In someembodiments, the temporary pairing token can be encrypted or digitallysigned using a key known only to identity server 320. Identity server320 can also generate a pair request entry, which can be, e.g., an entryin token repository 322 that includes the accessory RA, operator RA, andthe temporary paring token; the pair request entry can be a temporaryentry that is removed if the expiration time is reached withoutcompleting the relay pairing process. At block 708, identity server 320can send the temporary pairing token to accessory 304 (e.g., viaaccessory courier service 330). At block 710, accessory 304 can receivethe temporary pairing token.

At block 712, accessory 304 can provide the temporary pairing token tocontroller 302 via the local channel. For example, accessory 304 canupdate an appropriate characteristic of the remote relay access service,and controller 302 can receive a notification of the update. As anotherexample, accessory 304 can initiate block 702 in response to a requestfrom controller 302, and the temporary pairing token can be sent inresponse to that request at block 712. Controller 302 can receive thetemporary pairing token at block 714.

At block 716, controller 302 can send a request for an access token(which can be a persistent pairing token distinct from the temporarypairing token) to identity server 320. The request can include theoperator RA, the accessory RA, and the temporary pairing token. In someembodiments, the request at block 714 can also include otherinformation, e.g., information usable to verify the identity ofcontroller 302 with certificate server 310 (or another certificateserver, such as a server dedicated to verifying identity ofcontrollers).

At block 718, identity server 320 can generate an access token based onthe request from controller 302. In some embodiments, processing atblock 718 can include verifying the identity of controller 302 and/orverifying that the information included in the request (including thetemporary pairing token) matches the pair request entry created at block706. Assuming all verifications succeed, identity server 320 cangenerate an access token (which can be a persistent pairing tokendistinct from the temporary pairing token). The access token caninclude, e.g., a timestamp indicating when it was generated, anexpiration timestamp (if desired), the operator RA, the accessory RA, aflag indicating whether the operator RA is granted admin privilege forthe accessory (which can be set to true in this case), and otherinformation as desired. In some embodiments, the access token caninclude a version of the information that is digitally signed byidentity server 320, thereby providing an access token that is notreadily forged. At block 720, interaction server 320 can send the accesstoken to controller 302.

At block 722, controller 302 can receive the access token and canpersistently store the access token in association with the accessory RAof accessory 304. In some embodiments, controller 302 can associate theaccess token and accessory RA with a (presumably different) accessoryidentifier and accessory long-term public key used for local access, sothat controller 302 knows that the local identifier and the accessoryrelay alias both refer to the same accessory. At block 724, controller302 can provide the access token to accessory 304 via the local channel.At block 726, accessory 304 can receive the access token and canpersistently store the access token in association with the operator RAof controller 302; as noted above, the operator RA of controller 302 canbe associated with a (presumably different) controller identifier andcontroller long-term public key used for local access, so that accessory304 knows that both the local controller identifier and the operatorrelay alias refer to the same controller.

It will be appreciated that process 700 is illustrative and thatvariations and modifications are possible. Steps described as sequentialmay be executed in parallel, order of steps may be varied, and steps maybe modified, combined, added or omitted. In some embodiments, process700 can be initiated on request of a controller device.

Further, processes 400, 500, 600, and 700 (or portions thereof) can beperformed in a different order from that described. As noted above,certain operations within these processes may require communicationbetween controller 302 and accessory 304 on a local channel; however, itis not required that the local channel be continuously maintainedthroughout execution of the various processes involved in establishing arelay pairing. For instance, a controller can start the process while inthe local environment with the accessory, then leave the localenvironment and return later to finish. Further, in embodiments wherelocal access to an accessory is granted based on a user identifierrather than a specific device identifier, relay pairing setup can bestarted using one controller device and finished using a differentcontroller device operated by the same user.

An access token can be persistently stored and used indefinitely. Insome embodiments, an access token can have an expiration date set by theserver that generates it, either by default or based on an instructionfrom the controller. Thus, for example, an access token can be providedto allow a controller to have relay access to an accessory on atemporary basis (e.g., the controller might belong to a house-sitter orthe like).

In some embodiments, the relay pairing setup processes described abovecan be used to establish a relay pairing between a controller that hasadmin privilege (as established through local pairing) and an accessory.The processes can be repeated to establish relay pairings between acontroller and any number of accessories, provided that the controllerhas admin privilege as to each accessory. For controllers (or operators)that do not have admin privilege, a different process can be used to addrelay pairings; an example is described below.

Relay Use Examples

Once established, a relay pairing can be used at any time to relaymessages between a controller and an accessory. As noted above, themessages can conform to a uniform accessory protocol that can support arequest/response model for allowing the controller to interrogate (e.g.,via a read request) or modify (e.g., via a write request) variousaspects of accessory state (modeled, e.g., as characteristics that canbe readable and/or writeable by controllers). In addition, the uniformaccessory protocol can support notification by an accessory to one ormore controllers when some aspect of accessory state changes. Inaccordance with some embodiments of the present invention, uniformaccessory protocol messages can be exchanged via relay service 300.

In some embodiments, relay service 300 may limit the size of a relayrequest; for example, a single relay request payload may be limited tonot more than 4 kB (kilobytes), 16 kB, or the like. Some uniformaccessory protocol messages may exceed this limit (e.g., 500 kB to readan accessory attribute database). Where this is the case, messages canbe fragmented into multiple relay request payloads by the sender (e.g.,controller 302 or accessory 304). Each message fragment can include aportion of the message as well as fragmentation header information tofacilitate reassembly of the fragments. The fragmentation headerinformation can include, for instance, a transaction identifier (e.g., a16-bit monotonically increasing integer) that is common to all fragmentsof a message and distinguishes different messages from each other; atransaction length indicator (e.g., the number of bytes in the completemessage), and an index (e.g., a byte index indicating the location ofthe first byte of this fragment within the complete message). Therecipient of a fragmented message (e.g., accessory 304 or controller302) can use the transaction length indicator to allocate buffer spacefor the message and can assemble the message by writing each messagefragment into the allocated buffer space based on the index. Therecipient can use the transaction length indicator to determine when allbytes have been received. Thus, fragments of a message can be receivedout of order and placed back into order by the recipient.

FIGS. 8A and 8B show simplified flow diagrams of processes 800 a, 800 bfor communicating requests (process 800 a) and responses (process 800 b)between a controller (e.g., controller 302) and an accessory (e.g.,accessory 304) via a relay service (e.g., relay service 300) accordingto an embodiment of the present invention. In this example, it isassumed that a relay pairing has been established (e.g., as describedabove with reference to FIGS. 4-7), so that identity server 320 has apairing record in token repository 322 that associates an operator RA ofcontroller 302, an accessory RA of accessory 304, and a pairing token.

FIG. 8A shows process 800 a for communicating a request from controller302 to accessory 304. At blocks 802 and 804, accessory 304 can establisha (persistent) connection with accessory courier server 330. Forexample, accessory 304 can establish a socket with accessory courierserver 330; the socket can be mapped to the accessory RA of accessory304 (e.g., in mapping 332). To keep the socket open, accessory 304 cansend a request (e.g., a long-poll in HTTP) to accessory courier server330; the request can include the access token for any controller withwhich accessory 304 has a relay pairing. In some instances, an accessorycan have relay pairings with multiple controllers, and the request caninclude multiple access tokens, provided that the access tokens areassociated with the same accessory RA.

At block 808, controller 302 can generate a message to be sent toaccessory 304. The message can include, e.g., a read or write requestmessage conforming to the uniform accessory protocol. Block 808 canoccur whenever controller 302 determines that a message should becommunicated to accessory 304. For example, the user may operatecontroller 302 to request information about accessory 304 (e.g., “is thefront door locked?”) or to change the state of accessory 304 (e.g.,“lock the front door”). Alternatively, controller 302 may determine onits own initiative to send a message to accessory 304 (e.g., as a resultof an automated process).

At block 810, controller 302 can send one or more relay requests tocontroller courier service 340. The relay request(s) can include themessage content generated at block 808. In some embodiments, a messagemay be fragmented into multiple relay requests, e.g., as describedabove, and each relay request can include a fragment of the messagecontent and a fragmentation header. Along with the message content (orfragment thereof), the relay request(s) can include an indicator thatthe request is a relay request, the accessory RA for accessory 304, theoperator RA for controller 302, and the access token for the relaypairing between controller 302 and accessory 304. Block 810 can occurwhenever controller 302 determines that a message generated at block 808should be relayed to accessory 304 via relay service 300. For example,having determined that a message should be sent, controller 302 mayfurther determine that local access to accessory 304 is not currentlyavailable and that a relay pairing has been established with accessory304 so that access via relay service 300 is an option. In such cases,controller 302 can proceed to generate the request at block 810.

At block 812, controller courier server 340 can receive the relayrequest(s) from controller 302. In some embodiments, controller courierserver 340 may implement or support a number of different messagingservices for controllers and/or other user devices (e.g., acontroller-to-controller messaging service) in addition to relayservices described herein, and receiving each relay request can includedetermining (e.g., based on an indicator included in the request) thatthis request is to relay a message to an accessory.

At block 814, controller courier server 340 can verify the access token(e.g., by communicating with identity server 320, which can validate itsdigital signature on the access token and confirm that the access tokenis associated with the operator RA and accessory RA included in therelay request). Other validation operations, e.g., verifying theidentity of controller 302, can also be performed. Validation can beperformed independently for each relay request; controller courierserver 340 can be agnostic to message fragmentation. Assuming thevalidation operations succeed, at block 816, controller courier server340 can pass each relay request to accessory courier server 330. In someembodiments, controller courier server 340 can add a device-specificidentifier (DSID) to the request, which can be any identifier usable bycontroller courier server 340 to identify the specific controller device302 from which a relay request was received. This can allow any responseto a relay request to be selectively delivered to the controller devicethat made the request, rather than to all controller devices associatedwith a particular operator RA, as described below. Passing of the relayrequest(s) can be facilitated by message passing server 350 and caninclude reformatting the relay request(s), etc.

At block 820, accessory courier server 330 can receive the relayrequest(s). At block 822, accessory courier server 330 can send therelay request(s) to accessory 304, e.g., as a response to a previouslong-poll request from accessory 304 (as described above). Accessorycourier server 330 can be agnostic to the content of the request(s). Therelay request(s) as sent to accessory 304 can include the messagecontent (and fragmentation header if applicable) provided by controller302, the accessory RA, the operator RA, and the DSID added by controllercourier server 340. The access token can be omitted; accessory 304presumably already has a copy of the access token. In some embodiments,if accessory 304 is not connected to accessory courier server 340 when arelay request is received, the request can be discarded, and accessorycourier server 340 can report an error to controller courier server 330.

At block 824, accessory 304 can receive the relay request(s), includingthe message content provided by controller 302. If the message wasfragmented across multiple relay requests, accessory 304 can parse thefragmentation header and reassemble the complete message, e.g., in abuffer or other short-term memory. At block 826, accessory 304 canprocess the message. It should be noted that the message content can berelayed exactly as received, so that accessory 304 can process themessage in the same manner as it would process a message sent via alocal channel.

FIG. 8B shows process 800 b for communicating a response from accessory304 to controller 302. Process 800 b can be used, e.g., wheneveraccessory 304 determines that a response should be sent to controller302. In some embodiments, processing message content at block 826 ofprocess 800 a can result in accessory 304 generating a response messageto be sent to controller 302. For instance, in the case of a readrequest message, the response message can include the values of thecharacteristic(s) requested to be read; in the case of a write requestmessage, the response message can indicate success or failure. It is tobe understood that not every request message requires a separateresponse; in some instances, accessory 304 can consolidate responses tomultiple requests. Further, some request messages may generate multipleresponse messages. For instance, in cases where a request may take sometime to complete (e.g., opening a garage door), the accessory may send afirst response confirming receipt of the request and a second responseindicating completion of the request, or the accessory may wait and senda single response when the request is completed. In some embodiments,some requests may be processed without sending a response.

When a response message is to be sent, accessory 304 can generateresponse message content to be sent to controller 302 at block 828. Atblock 830, accessory 304 can send one or more relay request(s) toaccessory courier server 330 to relay the response message to controller302. The relay request(s) can be, e.g., HTTP or HTTPS request(s) thatinclude the response message content intended for controller 302 (e.g.,a message supported by the uniform accessory protocol). In someembodiments, a response message may be fragmented into multiple relayrequests, e.g., as described above, and each relay request can include afragment of the response message content and a fragmentation header.Along with the response message content (or fragment thereof), the relayrequest(s) to accessory courier server 330 can include an indicator thatthe request is a relay request, the operator RA for controller 302, theaccessory RA for accessory 304, and the access token for the relaypairing between controller 302 and accessory 304. Other information,such as the DSID for controller 302, can be included. The relayrequest(s) need not be identified as being responsive to a previousrelay request that was relayed from controller 302.

At block 832, accessory courier server 330 can receive the relayrequest(s) from accessory 304 and can determine that it is a relayrequest. At block 834, accessory courier service 330 can verify theaccess token (e.g., by communicating with identity server 320, which canvalidate its digital signature on the access token and confirm that theaccess token is associated with the accessory RA and operator RAincluded in the relay request). Other validation operations can also beperformed. Token verification (and any other validation operations) canbe performed independently for each relay request; accessory courierserver 330 can be agnostic to message fragmentation. Assuming the tokenverification (and any other validation operations) succeed, at block836, accessory courier server 330 can pass each relay request tocontroller courier server 340. Passing of the relay request(s) can befacilitated by message passing server 350 and can include reformattingthe request, etc.

At block 840, controller courier server 340 can receive the relayrequest(s). At block 842, controller courier server 340 can send therelay request(s) to controller 302. In some embodiments, controllercourier server 340 can use the DSID included in the relay request(s) todirect the relay request(s) to the specific controller device identifiedby the DSID; controller courier server 340 can be agnostic to thecontent of the relay request(s). Assuming controller 302 is online,controller 302 can receive the relay request(s) at block 850. In someembodiments, relay requests that contain response messages from anaccessory are not queued by controller courier server 340; if controller302 is offline, the response message may be discarded.

The relay request(s) as received by controller 302 at block 850 caninclude the message content (and fragmentation header if applicable)provided by controller 302. If the message was fragmented acrossmultiple relay requests, controller 302 can parse the fragmentationheader and reassemble the complete message, e.g., in a buffer or othershort-term memory. At block 852, controller 302 can process the responsemessage content. As with request messages sent by controller 302,response message content from accessory 304 can be relayed exactly assent, so that controller 302 can process the response message in thesame manner as it would process a response message sent via a localchannel. Processing of a response message might or might not lead to afurther request message.

Proceeding in this manner, controller 302 and accessory 304 can exchangeany messages supported by a uniform accessory protocol. For example, byexchanging messages via relay service 300, controller 302 and accessory304 can establish a pair-verified session (based on theirpreviously-established local pairing) and can encrypt subsequentmessages using a session key associated with the pair-verified session.In some embodiments, accessory 304 can refuse any requests to read orwrite various characteristics that are not received within the contextof a pair-verified session. Accordingly, end-to-end security betweencontroller 302 and accessory 304 can be provided.

Another type of message exchange can be an accessory notification. Insome embodiments, a notification can include any message sent by anaccessory that is not in response to a request message from acontroller. For example, the uniform accessory protocol may provide thata controller (e.g., controller 302) can subscribe to notifications ofstate changes occurring at accessory 304. The subscription can be at aglobal level (e.g., notify controller 302 of any state change) orspecific to a particular characteristic (or characteristics). When astate change occurs in a characteristic for which one or morecontrollers have subscribed to notifications, accessory 304 can generatea notification to each subscribed controller. Another circumstance inwhich a notification can be sent may include a configuration change tothe accessory, such as when a new accessory is added to a bridge. Stillanother circumstance may occur if the controller has requested periodicupdates as to the state of the accessory (e.g., an hourly temperaturereading). Depending on implementation, any of these or othercircumstances can result in an accessory generating a notification toone or more controllers. The particular content of a notificationmessage can depend on the controller and/or the transport; examples aredescribed in above-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/614,914 andU.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,891.

In some embodiments of the present invention, relay service 300 can beused to relay notifications from an accessory to subscribed controllers.FIG. 9 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process 900 for relaying anotification from an accessory (e.g., accessory 304) to a controller(e.g., controller 302) via a relay service (e.g., relay service 300)according to an embodiment of the present invention. As with FIGS. 8Aand 8B, in this example, it is assumed that a relay pairing has beenestablished (e.g., as described above with reference to FIGS. 4-7), sothat identity server 320 has a pairing record in token repository 322that associates an operator RA of controller 302, an accessory RA ofaccessory 304, and a pairing token.

At block 902, accessory 304 can determine that a notification should besent For example, if accessory 304 implements a door lock, a statechange can be from a locked state to an unlocked state (or vice versa).Any other aspect of accessory state that can change can also bedetected. In some embodiments, the accessory can update a value of oneof the characteristics of its accessory model to represent the statechange. As noted above, events or circumstances other than a statechange can also result in generation of a notification, and process 900can be performed whenever a notification is to be sent.

At block 904, accessory 304 can identify one or more controllers (e.g.,controller 302) that should be notified of a state change via relayservice 300. For example, in some embodiments, a controller can write toa “subscriptions” characteristic of the accessory model to establish (orterminate) a subscription to be notified in the event of a state change,either globally or for a specified subset of characteristics. Based onthe subscriptions characteristic(s) in its accessory model, accessory304 can determine whether any controllers are to be notified. (If nocontrollers are to be notified, process 900 can end at block 904.) Insome embodiments, having determined that one or more controllers (e.g.,controller 302) are to be notified, accessory 304 may further determinethat local access to controller 302 is not currently available and thata relay pairing has been created with controller 302 so that access viarelay service 300 is an option. In such cases, accessory 304 can proceedto post a notification to controller 302 at block 906. In someembodiments, the posted notification can be sent, e.g., as an HTTP orHTTPS POST request to a designated URL at accessory courier server 330.The posted notification can include an indicator to indicate generallythe type of circumstance that occurred (e.g., a state change,configuration change, new sensor reading available) without providingany further information (e.g., what changed or what the new reading is).The posted notification can also include the accessory RA and a list ofoperator RAs and associated access tokens for controllers to which thenotification should be relayed. A single notification can be posted forany number of controllers.

At block 910, accessory courier server 330 can receive the postednotification. In some embodiments, accessory courier server 340 candistinguish posted notifications from relay requests (e.g., they can beposted to different URLs). At block 912, accessory courier server 330can verify the access token(s) (e.g., by communicating with identityserver 320, which can validate its digital signature on each accesstoken and confirm that each access token is correctly associated withthe accessory RA and operator RA specified by accessory 304). Assumingthe access token for a particular operator RA is valid, at block 914,accessory courier server 330 can pass a notification message for thatoperator RA to controller courier server 340. Passing of thenotification message can be facilitated by message passing server 350and can include reformatting the notification message, etc.

At block 920, controller courier server 340 can receive the notificationmessage (or messages as the case may be). At block 922, controllercourier service can send each received notification message to anappropriate controller (e.g., controller 302) based on the operator RA.Where the operator RA maps to a user account rather than a specificcontroller device, this can result in sending notifications to multiplecontroller devices associated with the same user account. In someembodiments, notification messages can be queued by controller courierserver 340 for later delivery if controller 302 is offline. Queuednotification messages can be retained as long as desired beforediscarding (e.g., 7 days, 30 days, or some other time period). Queuingof notifications can be independent of whether otheraccessory-originated relay requests are queued.

At block 930, controller 302 can receive the notification message fromcontroller courier server 340. As noted above, the notification messagecan indicate generally the type of circumstance that occurred (e.g., astate change, configuration change, new sensor reading available)without providing any further information (e.g., what changed or whatthe new reading is). Controller 302 can, if desired, obtain informationabout the nature of the state change by initiating a message toaccessory 304 at block 932. The message can be, e.g., a read request toread characteristics of interest to determine further information aboutthe state change. The message can be sent to accessory 304 in the samemanner as any other read request (or write request), e.g., using process800 a described above to relay the message via relay service 300.

It will be appreciated that processes 800 a, 800 b, and 900 areillustrative and that variations and modifications are possible. Stepsdescribed as sequential may be executed in parallel, order of steps maybe varied, and steps may be modified, combined, added or omitted. Forinstance, an accessory can use process 800 b to send a message to aparticular controller device that is not responsive to a request messagefrom that device; provided that the accessory has a device-specificidentifier of the controller, the message need not be responsive to arequest message. As another example, if the accessory has adevice-specific identifier for a particular controller device, anotification sent using process 900 can be directed to a specificcontroller device.

The message formats used within relay service 300 can be such that relayservice 300 does not know that a particular message originating fromaccessory 304 is a response to a controller message, or to any specificcontroller message. Message content can be generated by the originatingendpoint device (either controller 302 or accessory 304 as the case maybe) and can be opaque to relay service 300. Thus, for example,controller 302 and accessory 304 can exchange messages conforming to theuniform accessory protocol to establish a pair-verified session witheach other and to communicate encrypted information within thepair-verified session. In some embodiments, a message identifier(message ID) can be assigned to each message, either by the originatingendpoint (controller 302 or accessory 304) or by relay service 300. Themessage ID can be delivered to the recipient and can be used by therecipient, e.g., to associate a response message with the requestmessage (or multiple request messages) to which the response isresponsive.

If an attempt to relay a message fails at any point, a failure responsecan be generated and delivered to the endpoint device that sent therelay request. The endpoint device that receives the failure responsecan determine whether to retry, alert the user, take other action, ortake no action.

Accessory 304 can maintain a persistent connection (e.g., socket) toaccessory courier service 330. For example, as described above,accessory 304 can send an HTTP long-poll request to accessory courierserver 330 in order to keep the connection open, and accessory courierserver 330 can deliver a relayed message as a response to the long-pollrequest. Any time accessory 304 receives a response to a long-pollrequest, it can generate and send another long-poll request, therebyallowing the connection to persist indefinitely. In examples describedherein, the connection to accessory courier server 330 is establishedbased on a request (e.g., a long-poll) received at accessory courierserver 330 from accessory 304 that includes the accessory RA (and accesstoken for each controller 302 from which accessory 304 is able toreceive messages). Accessory courier server 330, and relay service 300more generally, need not provide a mechanism for delivering requests toaccessories that are not currently connected. Thus, accessory courierserver 330 does not need to retain any information as to where or how tolocate accessory 304; as long as accessory 304 maintains a connection(e.g., socket) to accessory courier server 330, the presence of thesocket is sufficient to allow accessory courier server 330 to deliverrequests. It should be noted that, given this implementation, ifaccessory 304 does not maintain a connection to accessory courier server330, relay service 300 may be unable to complete a relay request fromcontroller 302.

In some embodiments, relay service 300 can keep a log of activity atvarious servers. For example, when controller courier server 340 (and/oraccessory courier server 330) relays a message, the accessory RA,operator RA, and direction of the message (controller-to-accessory oraccessory-to-controller) can be recorded; the message content need notbe recorded. This can allow relay service 300 to monitor activity levelsand detect patterns (e.g., trends in usage, anomalies as describedbelow) without having a record of what information was sent. Keeping anylog or activity record is optional.

Adding and Removing Users

In some embodiments, it may be desirable to allow multiple users (ormultiple controllers) to interact with an accessory, via local accessand/or via relay service 300. In the context of local access, acontroller that has admin privilege as to a particular accessory can addother controllers using a pair add process of the uniform accessoryprotocol. In the context of relay service 300, a controller that hasadmin privilege as to a particular accessory can add relay pairings withother operator RAs (e.g., operator RAs that belong to different users).

FIGS. 10A and 10B show a simplified flow diagram of a process 1000 foradding a relay pairing for a user according to an embodiment of thepresent invention. Process 1000 can be implemented, e.g., in “admin”controller 1002 (e.g., a controller such as controller 302 describedabove that has established a relay pairing with at least one accessoryusing the processes of FIGS. 4-7) interacting with identity server 320and with a “new” controller 1004, which can be a controller belonging toa different user from the user of admin controller 1002. In thisexample, it is assumed that controller courier server 340 implements acontroller-to-controller messaging service (e.g., similar to theiMessage® service of Apple Inc.) and that admin controller 1002 and newcontroller 1004 can communicate via controller courier service 340.Other implementations are possible, provided that some communicationchannel exists between admin controller 1002 and new controller 1004.

Referring first to FIG. 10A, process 1000 can begin when admincontroller 1002 determines that a relay pairing of new controller 1004with one or more accessories should be added. In this case, admincontroller 1002 already has a relay pairing with each accessory inquestion. For example, admin controller 1002 may be used to manageaccessories in a home, and new controller 1004 may belong to a user(e.g., roommate) who is moving into the home or who has not yet beenadded as an operator on relay service 300. In some embodiments, a userinterface of admin controller 1002 may allow the admin user to identifythe user to be added. Users can be identified in this context, e.g., byreference to a phone number, email address, or other item of informationthat can link them to one or more controller devices and/or to a useraccount with relay service 300. In some embodiments, the admincontroller's user interface may allow the admin user to select a user tobe added from a contacts list in which personal information of variousindividuals known to the admin user is stored. Other implementations arepossible.

At block 1010, admin controller 1002 can send a message to newcontroller 1004 (also denoted “C2”) requesting consent to add the userof new controller 1004 as an operator on relay service 300. The messagecan include a list of accessory RAs for the accessories for which arelay pairing is proposed to be established (which can include any orall accessories with which admin controller 1002 has a relay pairing),the operator RA of admin controller 1002 and an invitation code (whichcan be a code number recognizable to admin controller 1002 that can beused for bookkeeping related to consent requests). As noted above,controller-to-controller messaging via controller courier server 340 canbe used. At block 1012, new controller 1004 can receive the message.

At block 1014, new controller 1004 can determine whether consent shouldbe granted. For example, new controller 1004 can prompt its user forconfirmation. Other techniques can also be used. In some embodiments, ifnew controller 1004 determines that consent should not be granted,process 1000 can end.

Assuming consent should be granted, at block 1016, new controller 1004can obtain an operator RA for accessing relay service 300. Newcontroller 1004 can obtain an operator RA in the same manner asdescribed above for controller 302, e.g., by executing process 500. Atblock 1018, new controller 1004 can send a request for a consent tokento identity server 320. The request can include, e.g., the operator RAof new controller 1004, other information usable to verify the identityof new controller 1004 with certificate server 310 (or anothercertificate server, such as a server dedicated to verifying identity ofcontrollers), the operator RA of admin controller 1002, the list ofaccessory RAs received from admin controller 1002, and (if desired) anexpiration time.

At block 1020, identity server 320 can receive the request for a consenttoken. At block 1022, identity server 320 can generate a set of consenttokens, one for each accessory RA. The consent token for a givenaccessory RA can include, e.g., the accessory RA, the operator RA ofadmin controller 1002, the operator RA of new controller 1004, atimestamp indicating when the consent token was generated, and anexpiration time (which can be, e.g., 1 day, 7 days, or the like afterthe generation time; an expiration time specified in the request atblock 1018 can be used). At block 1022, identity server 320 can send theconsent token(s) to new controller 1004; each consent token can beassociated with the corresponding accessory RA. Similarly to thetemporary pairing token described above, identity server 320 can store atemporary token record for each consent token. At block 1026, newcontroller 1004 can receive the consent token(s).

As shown in FIG. 10B, having received the consent tokens, at block 1028,new controller 1004 can send a message to admin controller 1002,responsive to the request for consent. The message can include theconsent token(s) received from identity server 320 at block 1026, witheach consent token being associated with the corresponding accessory RA,as well as the invitation code that was included in the message fromadmin controller 1002 at block 1010. As noted above,controller-to-controller messaging via controller courier server 340 canbe used. At block 1030, admin controller 1002 can receive the message.

At block 1032, admin controller 1002 can send a request to identityserver 320 to retrieve an access token for a relay pairing between newcontroller 1004 and each accessory RA for which a consent token wasreceived. The request can include, e.g., the accessory RA(s), theconsent token corresponding to each accessory RA, the operator RA ofadmin controller 1002, and the access token for the already-establishedrelay pairing between admin controller 1002 and one or more of theaccessory RAs. Other information can also be included, such asinformation usable to verify the identity of new controller 1004 withcertificate server 310 (or another certificate server, such as a serverdedicated to verifying identity of controllers), an identifier of thenew user (e.g., an email address or account identifier), etc.

At block 1034, identity server 320 can receive the request from admincontroller 1002. At block 1036, identity server 320 can generate one ormore access tokens for new controller 1004 based on the request. In someembodiments, processing at block 1036 can include verifying the identityof admin controller 1002 and/or verifying that the information includedin the request matches the consent token that was temporarily stored.Assuming all verifications succeed, interaction server 320 can generatean access token for the operator RA of new controller 1004 and eachaccessory RA. Each access token can have the same structure as theaccess token generated at block 718 of process 700 described above. Insome embodiments, access tokens established using a consent token canhave the admin flag set to false. In other embodiments, the request fromadmin controller 1002 sent at block 1032 can specify whether the adminflag should be true or false for a particular new controller's operatorRA. At block 1038, interaction server 320 can send the new accesstoken(s) to admin controller 1002. Each access token can be associatedwith the accessory RA for which it is valid.

At block 1040, admin controller 1002 can receive the access token(s). Atblock 1042, admin controller 1002 can provide the new access token andthe operator RA of new controller 1004 to each accessory, based on theaccessory RAs. In some embodiments, new access tokens can be providedusing messages conforming to the uniform accessory protocol, e.g., bywriting to an appropriate characteristic of the accessory's remote relayaccess service. The messages can be communicated using a local channeland/or relay service 300 (e.g., depending on where admin controller 1002is located at the relevant time).

At block 1044, admin controller 1002 can send a message to newcontroller 1004 that includes new pairing token associated with eachaccessory RA. At block 1046, new controller 1004 can receive the messagefrom admin controller 1002 and can persistently store the accessory RAsin association with the access tokens. In some embodiments, the messageat block 1044 is not sent until after the accessories have received thenew pairing token, used the new pairing token to establish a newconnection with accessory courier server 340 for communicating with newcontroller 1004, and confirmed the connection to admin controller 1002.This allows new controller 1004 to begin interacting with accessoriesvia relay service 300 immediately after receipt of the message at block1046.

It will be appreciated that process 1000 is illustrative and thatvariations and modifications are possible. Steps described as sequentialmay be executed in parallel, order of steps may be varied, and steps maybe modified, combined, added or omitted. In this example, new controller1004 might or might not have a local pairing established with a givenaccessory when process 1000 is performed, and new controller 1004 mightor might not be able to determine that a given accessory RA and relaypairing token correspond to a particular local pairing. In someimplementations, admin controller 1002 can provide correspondenceinformation to new accessory 1004 to facilitate identifying arelay-paired accessory and a local-paired accessory as being the sameaccessory. For example, as described above, admin controller 1002 canmaintain an environment model for an environment where the accessoriesare located. The environment model can associate local accessoryidentifiers with corresponding accessory RAs. The environment model canbe synchronized to new controller 1004, e.g., as described inabove-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,912. In someembodiments, new controller 1004 can infer correspondences based on itscommunications with various accessories. Similarly the accessories withwhich new controller 1004 obtains a relay pairing via process 1000 mightor might associate the relay pairing with a local pairing to the samecontroller. For example, admin controller 1002 can provide thecorresponding local controller ID to the accessories along with theoperator RA.

In some embodiments, a controller with admin privileges may be able toremove an established relay pairing for another controller. For example,new controller 1004 of FIG. 10 can send a message to admin controller1002 requesting to have its relay pairings removed, or admin controller1002 can determine that new controller 1004 should have its relaypairings removed (e.g., based on input from the admin user).

FIG. 11 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process 1100 for removing arelay pairing according to an embodiment of the present invention.Process 1100 can be implemented, e.g., by admin controller 1002 (asdescribed above with reference to FIG. 10) communicating with anaccessory 304 (or separately with each of multiple accessories, notshown) and with another controller 1104 that is to be removed. In someembodiments, controller 1104 can be a controller that was added as newcontroller 1004 using process 1000. Communication between admincontroller 1002 and other controller 1104 can usecontroller-to-controller messaging via controller courier server 340 asdescribed above; communication between admin controller 1002 andaccessory 304 can use either a local channel or relay service 300 (e.g.,depending on where admin controller 1002 is located at the relevanttime).

Process 1100 can begin at block 1110, when admin controller 1002determines that a relay pairing of other controller 1104 with accessory304 should be removed. This can be part of removing all access rights toaccessory 304 (and other accessories in a given environment) from othercontroller 1002, or the decision to remove can be more selective (e.g.,per accessory). In some embodiments, a relay pairing can be removedwithout also removing a local pairing; in other embodiments, removingone type of pairing can result in removing both. In some embodiments,other controller 1104 can send a message to admin controller 1002requesting removal. In other embodiments, admin controller can receivean instruction via a user interface to remove another user (or specificcontroller). Other determination logic can also be used.

At block 1112, admin controller 1002 can send a request to accessory 304to remove other controller 1104. The request can be implemented, e.g.,as a write request to an appropriate characteristic of the remote relayaccess service of accessory 304. The request can include the operator RAof other controller 1104. The request can be sent via a local channel orvia relay service 300, depending on available communication channels ata given time.

At block 1114, accessory 304 can receive the request. At block 1116,accessory 304 can remove the operator RA and associated access token forother controller 1104 from its list of established relay pairings.Thereafter, accessory 304 does not attempt to communicate withcontroller 1104 via relay service 300. In some embodiments, a localpairing with other controller 1104 may remain until it is removed via aseparate request. In other embodiments, a request to remove a relaypairing with a particular controller can also result in removing a localpairing associated with the same controller. For example, admincontroller 1002 can also issue a request to accessory 304 to remove thelocal pairing with other controller 1004 as part of process 1100. Atblock 1117, accessory 304 can send a response to admin controller 1002confirming the removal. In some embodiments, if admin controller 1002does not receive a response, admin controller 1002 can initiate adifferent action to remove the relay pairing (e.g., resetting theaccessory or prompting the user to reset the accessory).

At block 1118, admin controller 1002 can send a message to othercontroller 1104 instructing controller 1104 to remove its relaypairing(s). The message can include a list of accessory RAs for whichrelay pairings are to be removed. In some embodiments, accessories forwhich relay pairings are to be removed can be identified as a group. Forinstance, if the accessory RAs are associated with an environment modelof the local environment in which the accessories physically reside, theenvironment model can have an identifier, and admin controller 1002 caninstruct other controller 1104 to remove the relay pairings for allaccessory RAs associated with the environment model. As noted above,controller-to-controller messaging via controller courier server 340 canbe used.

At block 1120, other controller 1104 can receive the message. At block1122, other controller 1104 can remove the accessory RAs and associatedaccess tokens as instructed. The removal process can result in removingany information about the accessories from other controller 1104(including, in some embodiments, local pairings). In some embodiments,blocks 1120 and 1122 can be implemented within a communication daemon incontroller 1104 so that they occur automatically (and optionallytransparently to a user) on receipt of the message at block 1120. Ifprocess 1100 was initiated based on a message from other controller 1104requesting removal, blocks 1118 and 1120 can be omitted, and controller1104 can remove the accessory RAs on its own initiative.

It will be appreciated that process 1100 is illustrative and thatvariations and modifications are possible. Steps described as sequentialmay be executed in parallel, order of steps may be varied, and steps maybe modified, combined, added or omitted. In this example, neithercontroller notifies identity server 320 of the removal. Since the accesstokens are removed at the endpoints, the continued presence of a recordfor the access token in repository 322 of identity server 320 does notenable any communication between controller 1104 and accessory 304 afterprocess 1100 has executed. In some embodiments, admin controller 1002can send a cleanup request to identity server 320 to revoke the tokenrecord for the access token, e.g., by removing the token record fromtoken repository 322. In some embodiments, token records can expire fromrepository 322, e.g., based on an expiration timestamp included in theaccess token as described above, and identity server 320 canperiodically remove records where the access token has expired. Otherprocesses can also be used.

Pass Server Example

As described above, relay service 300 can know that communication isoccurring between controllers and accessories but may not know thecontent of such communication. Relay service 300 can also have someinformation as to the volume of traffic associated with particularaccessory RAs or types of accessories, e.g., by implementing a reportingservice as described below. In some embodiments, relay service 300 canblock accessories that are known or suspected to generate excessivetraffic (or to exhibit other anomalous or undesirable behavior inrelation to relay service 300) from connecting to accessory courierserver 330. This can be done without relay service 300 storinginformation associating an accessory RA with an accessory type or otheraccessory-identifying information.

In some embodiments, pass server 360 can be used for blockingaccessories associated with anomalous behavior. For example, whenaccessory 304 requests a connection to accessory courier server 330,accessory courier server 330 can require accessory 304 to present avalid pass. Accessory 304 can obtain a pass from pass server 360 andpresent the pass to accessory courier server 330.

FIG. 12 shows a simplified flow diagram of a process 1200 forestablishing a connection between an accessory (e.g., accessory 304) andan accessory courier server (e.g., accessory courier server 330)according to an embodiment of the present invention. Portions of process1200 can be performed by accessory 304 interacting with pass server 360,and portions of process 1200 can be performed by accessory 304interacting with accessory courier server 330.

Process 1200 can begin at any time when accessory 304 determines that aconnection to accessory courier server 330 should be established. Atblock 1202, accessory 304 can send a request for a pass to pass server360. The request can include accessory-identifying information foraccessory 304, such as manufacturer, model, firmware version, etc. Inthis example, the pass request does not include the accessory RA or anyoperator RA.

At block 1204, pass server 360 can receive the request, and at block1206, pass server 360 can determine whether access by accessory 304 ispermitted. For example, pass server 360 can determine whether theaccessory identifying information corresponds to an entry in blacklist362 (creation and updating of blacklist 362 is described below). In someembodiments, access is permitted unless accessory 304 is on blacklist362. Other decision criteria can also be supported. If, at block, 1206,it is determined that access is not permitted, the request can be deniedat block 1208, and process 1200 can end.

If, at block 1206, it is determined that access is permitted, then atblock 1210, pass server 360 can generate a pass. The pass can include atimestamp when the pass was generated, a code (e.g., a digitalsignature) generated by the pass server, and/or other data as desired.In some embodiments, the pass does not contain any information specificto accessory 304 or to a particular transaction with pass server 360.For example, the pass generation process can be implemented such thatall passes generated within a particular time period (e.g., 5-minutegranularity) are identical, so that a pass cannot be linked by relayservice 300 to a specific transaction at pass server 360.

At block 1212, accessory 304 can receive the pass from pass server 360.At block 1214, accessory 304 can send a connection request to accessorycourier server 330. The connection request can include the accessory RAfor accessory 304 and an access token and operator RA for eachcontroller with which accessory 304 intends to be able to exchangemessages using relay service 300. The connection request can alsoinclude the pass received from pass server 360.

At block 1216, accessory courier service 330 can receive the connectionrequest from accessory 304. At block 1218, accessory courier service 330can determine whether the pass included in the request is valid. Forinstance, accessory courier service 330 may send the pass to pass server360 for validation, or accessory courier service 330 may receiveinformation from pass server 360 that is usable to validate the pass(e.g., a list of timestamps and associated codes). If, at block 1218,the pass is not valid, accessory courier server 330 can deny the requestat block 1220, and process 1200 can end.

If, at block 1218, the pass is valid, then at block 1222, accessorycourier server 330 can continue with establishing the connection. Forexample, accessory 304 may be required to authenticate using its PKIcertificate and UUID as described above, and access tokens presented byaccessory 304 in the connection request can be validated by accessorycourier server 330. Assuming such operations are successfully completed,the connection can be established.

It will be appreciated that process 1200 is illustrative and thatvariations and modifications are possible. Steps described as sequentialmay be executed in parallel, order of steps may be varied, and steps maybe modified, combined, added or omitted. In some embodiments, necessarycourier server 340 can require an accessory that remains connected torenew its pass periodically, e.g., by sending a request for a new passto an accessory via the open connection. The renewal period can be,e.g., every 24 or 48 hours. Use of pass server 360 can allow accessorieswhose presence may impair the functioning of relay service 300 (e.g., bygenerating excessive traffic) to be excluded while avoiding the need tohave relay service 300 retain accessory identifying information (e.g.,manufacturer, model, etc.) for specific accessories. For example, passserver 360 can discard any accessory-identifying information it receivesimmediately upon generating a pass (or denying a pass request). Passserver 360 in this example does not receive the accessory RA, so theaccessory RA does not become associated (even temporarily) with anyaccessory-identifying information provided in the pass request. Further,pass server 360 can generate passes in a manner that a pass is notconnected with a specific transaction (e.g., multiple accessories canreceive the same pass), so relay server 330 cannot tie a particularconnection to accessory courier server 330 to a specific accessory oraccessory type. This can facilitate protection of user privacy.

Reporting Example

In some embodiments, pass server 360 can use blacklist 362 to makedecisions regarding whether to issue a pass in response to a passrequest from an accessory. Blacklist 362 can be populated dynamicallybased on anomalous activity detected at relay service 300. As usedherein, “anomalous activity” by an accessory can include any sort ofunusual or unexpected activity that may have an adverse effect onoperation of relay service 300. For example, a particular accessory ormany accessories of similar type may begin sending state-changenotifications at an unusually high rate, or an accessory connection maybecome unstable, resulting in a high rate of disconnect-and-reconnectevents at accessory courier server 330. Such events may be the result offirmware changes that contain bugs or other issues that may arise in aparticular implementation of an accessory.

As described above, some embodiments of relay service 300 avoidretaining information usable by third parties to identify a particularaccessory as being of a particular type. For instance, as describedabove, the accessory RA can be decoupled from such accessory-identifyinginformation as manufacturer, model accessory location, etc. In onespecific example, certificate server 310 may receive a digital securitycertificate from an accessory, and the certificate may be connected witha particular manufacturer, model, or class of accessories. Thus, it ispossible that the digital security certificate might reveal informationabout the accessory's identity and/or functionality. However, asdescribed above, certificate server 310 can validate the digitalsecurity certificate, then generate a PKI certificate and deviceidentity token (e.g., UUID) that need not be correlated in any way withinformation in the digital security certificate, or any correlation canbe encoded in such a way that only certificate server 310 can decipherit. Certificate server 310 can retain just the PKI certificate and UUIDfor future authentication operations. Subsequently, the accessory canuse the PKI certificate and UUID to obtain an accessory RA fromaccessory courier server 330. The accessory RA can be randomly orpseudorandomly assigned and can be uncorrelated with the PKI certificateand associated UUID. As a result, the accessory's identity and/orfunctionality can be dissociated from the identification of theaccessory within relay service 300, in such a way that third partiescannot infer accessory identity or functionality based on messageexchanged with relay service 300.

Despite these privacy protections, it may be desirable to provide somediagnostic ability to trace anomalous accessory behavior to a source(e.g., a specific type of accessory). In some embodiments, reportingserver 370 of FIG. 3 can support a diagnostic process.

FIG. 13 shows a simplified flow diagram of a diagnostic process 1300according to an embodiment of the present invention. Portions of process1300 can be implemented, e.g., in reporting server 370.

At block 1302, process 1300 can detect anomalous activity. In someembodiments, anomalous activity can be detected based on analysis ofrelay service logs. The logs can record, for instance, when relaymessages were sent, the operator RA and accessory RA, direction of therelay message, and message size. Other events, such as when an accessoryRA connected to accessory courier server 330 or disconnected fromaccessory courier server 330, or unsuccessful connection attempts, canalso be logged. The logs need not record message content, access tokens,or any other information. Analysis at block 1302 can include applyingstatistical algorithms to define a baseline pattern of accessorybehavior, and accessory RAs that begin to deviate significantly from thebaseline can be identified as having anomalous activity. Other sourcesof information can also be used to detect anomalies, such as performancemetrics associated with various servers in relay service 300, networktraffic patterns, and so on. Analysis at block 1302 can be performed,e.g., using automated processes implemented in reporting server 370and/or human analysts.

At block 1304, a pattern of anomalous activity involving a large numberof accessories associated with different operator RAs can be identified.A “large” number in this context can be defined, e.g., as enoughaccessories that at least 100 different operator RAs are associated withthe accessory RAs. The exact threshold for a “large” number can beselected based on the goal of identifying relatively widespreadanomalies and also preserving user privacy throughout the diagnosticprocess (e.g., as described below). Detection of anomalous patterns canbe based on automated processes implemented in reporting server 370. Insome embodiments, human reviewers may be involved in detecting and/orconfirming anomalous patterns. If no anomalous patterns are detected, orif an anomalous pattern involving less than the threshold number ofoperator RAs is detected, then no further investigation is performed.

Assuming further investigation is to be performed, at block 1306, aninvestigation ID can be assigned to the identified pattern of anomalousactivity. The investigation ID can be a sequentially or randomlyassigned number or the like. As described below, the investigation ID isused to gather responses to requests for information associated with theinvestigation. In some embodiments, reporting server 370 can assign theinvestigation ID.

At block 1308, investigation request messages can be generated and sentto the operator RAs associated with the anomalous activity. As notedabove, in some embodiments, an investigation is only initiated if thenumber of operator RAs exceeds a threshold for being considered large(e.g., 100 or more). The investigation request messages can be sentusing controller courier server 340. The investigation request messagecan include a request for accessory identifying information for theaccessory RA involved in the anomalous pattern. The investigationmessage can also include the investigation ID. At block 1310, responsesto the investigation request messages can be received. A specificexample of sending investigation request messages and receivingresponses is described below.

In some embodiments, the responses received at block 1310 can includejust the investigation ID and accessory-identifying information (e.g.,manufacture and model, firmware version, etc.). The accessory RA and/oroperator RA need not be included, so that reporting server 370 does notassociate the accessory-identifying information with the accessory RA orthe operator RA. Instead, the accessory-identifying information isassociated only with the investigation ID.

At block 1312, reporting server 370 (or a human reviewer) can analyzethe responses associated with a particular investigation ID to attemptto trace the anomalous activity to a specific accessory type (e.g., aparticular model of garage door opener or an accessory running aparticular firmware version).

At block 1314, follow-up action can be initiated based on the results ofthe analysis at block 1312. Depending on incident-specific details, suchas severity of the anomaly, strength of the correlation to a particularaccessory type, etc., various specific follow-up actions can be taken.For example, the accessory type can be added to blacklist 362. Inaddition or instead, a manufacturer of the accessory to which anomalousactivity is traced can be notified, which can allow the manufacturer toinvestigate and address the problem (e.g., with a firmware upgrade).

FIG. 14 shows a simplified flow diagram of an investigation process 1400according to an embodiment of the present invention. Process 1400, whichcan be used in conjunction with process 1300, can include generatinginvestigation request messages to controllers and receiving responses.

Process 1400 can begin at block 1402, when reporting server 370determines that investigation is appropriate, e.g., as a result ofexecuting block 1304 of process 1300 described above. At block 1402,reporting server 370 can select a set of operator RAs to receiveinvestigation request messages and can assign an investigation ID to theinvestigation. The set of operator RAs can be a large set (e.g., atleast 100 different operator RAs as described above). In someembodiments, all operator RAs that are associated with a pattern ofanomalous activity can be selected; alternatively, a subset of operatorRAs can be randomly selected. At block 1404, reporting server 370 caninitiate investigation request messages to the selected operator RAs.For instance, reporting server 370 can generate a request message toeach operator RA, including the investigation ID and a list of one ormore accessory RAs associated with both the operator RA and theanomalous activity. Reporting server 370 can provide the request messageto controller courier server 340.

At block 1406, controller courier server 340 can receive theinvestigation request message for a particular operator RA fromreporting server 370. Controller courier server 340 can generate aninvestigation query to one or more controllers (e.g., controller 302)associated with each operator RA. The investigation query to controller302 can include the investigation ID and the list of accessory RAs thatare associated with the operator RA of controller 302 and the anomalousactivity. Controller courier server 340 can send the investigation queryto controller 302.

At block 1408, controller 302 can receive the investigation query. Atblock 1410, controller 302 can identify the relevant accessory based onthe received accessory RA. For example, as described above controller302 may store an accessory model or environment model that associatesthe accessory RA assigned by relay service 300 with a model of aspecific accessory's capabilities and functions; the accessory model orenvironment model can include accessory-identifying information such asmanufacturer, model, serial number, firmware version, etc. At block1410, controller 302 can access the stored information for the accessoryassociated with the accessory RA and retrieve accessory-identifyinginformation.

At block 1412, controller 302 can obtain user approval to respond to theinvestigation query. For example, controller 302 can present a prompt tothe user. The prompt can indicate that relay service 300 isinvestigating anomalous activity and would like to receive informationabout an accessory (or multiple accessories) associated with theanomalous activity. The prompt can identify the accessory in question(e.g., based on the determination at block 1410). If the user declines,process 1400 can end without sending a report back to reporting server370. In some embodiments, controller 302 can simply not respond to theinvestigation query if the user declines.

Assuming the user approves, at block 1414, controller 302 can generate areport message responsive to the investigation query. The report messagecan include some or all of the accessory-identifying informationretrieved at block 1410 as well as the investigation ID that wasincluded in the investigation query. The report message does not need toinclude the accessory RA or operator RA. At block 1416, controller 302can send the report message to controller courier server 340.

At block 1418, controller courier server 340 can receive the reportmessage from controller 302 and can forward selected information fromthe report message to reporting server 370. For example, controllercourier server 340 can forward the investigation ID and theaccessory-identifying information but not any information identifyingthe controller or operator.

At block 1420, reporting server 370 can collect the informationforwarded by controller courier server 340 and can perform furtheranalysis and operations, e.g., in accordance with blocks 1310, 1312,1314 of process 1300. It should be noted that, via process 1400,reporting server 370 need not obtain any information associatingspecific accessories with specific accessory RAs or with specificcontrollers or operator RAs. Instead, based on the information forwardedby controller courier server 340, reporting server 370 can assemble alist of accessory-identifying information for accessories associatedwith the anomalous activity (based on the investigation ID), withoutbeing able to associate a particular item of accessory-identifyinginformation with any controller or operator. The fact that reportingserver 370 only initiates an investigation if a large number of operatorRAs are involved can help to prevent reporting server 370 fromassociating the received information with any specific operator RA fromthe original set of requests at block 1404. In fact, reporting server370 need not know which operator RAs responded or not.

It will be appreciated that processes 1300 and 1400 are illustrative andthat variations and modifications are possible. Steps described assequential may be executed in parallel, order of steps may be varied,and steps may be modified, combined, added or omitted. An investigationcan be held open awaiting controller responses for as long as desired(e.g., a day, a week, ten days, a month), and the investigation ID canbe used to track which investigations are still open. If a response toan investigation query is received after an investigation is closed, theresponse can be discarded based on the investigation ID. Thus, acontroller need not determine whether an investigation is still openprior to sending a response. Further, the use of investigation IDs canallow multiple investigations of different anomalous patterns to beconducted concurrently. In some instances, an investigation need notlead to further action. For instance, reporting server 370 might notreceive enough information to reliably trace the anomaly to a specifictype of accessory, or even a large amount of received information mightnot reveal a correlation with a specific type of accessory.

Example Device Architectures

FIG. 15 shows a simplified block diagram of a computer system 1500according to an embodiment of the present invention. In someembodiments, computer system 1500 can implement any or all of thefunctions, behaviors, and capabilities described herein as beingperformed by a server (e.g., any of the servers of relay service 300 ofFIG. 3), as well as other functions, behaviors, and capabilities notexpressly described. In some embodiments, other physical instances ofcomputer system 1500 can implement any or all of the functions,behaviors, and capabilities described herein as being performed by acontroller (e.g., controller 302 of FIG. 3) or an accessory (e.g.,accessory 304 of FIG. 3); further examples of controller and accessoryimplementations are described below.

Computer system 1500 can include processing subsystem 1502, storagesubsystem 1504, user interface 1506, and network interface 1508.Computer system 1500 can also include other components (not explicitlyshown) such as a battery, power controllers, and other componentsoperable to provide various enhanced capabilities. In some embodiments(e.g., for a controller), computer system 1500 can be implemented in aconsumer electronic device such as a desktop or laptop computer, tabletcomputer, smart phone, other mobile phone, wearable device, mediadevice. household appliance, or the like. Computer system 1500 can alsobe implemented (e.g., for relay service 300) in a large-scalearchitecture such as a scalable server system or server farm that caninclude many interconnected processors, storage systems and interfaces,capable of processing and responding to high volumes of requests fromclient devices including controllers and/or accessories.

Storage subsystem 1504 can be implemented, e.g., using disk, flashmemory, or any other non-transitory storage medium, or a combination ofmedia, and can include volatile and/or non-volatile storage media. Insome embodiments, storage subsystem 1504 can store one or moreapplication and/or operating system programs to be executed byprocessing subsystem 1502, including programs to implement any or alloperations described herein as being performed by any of the servers ofrelay service 300 as well as data associated with such operations (e.g.,token repository 322 and other stored data collections). In instanceswhere computer system 1500 implements a server, storage subsystem 1504can be implemented using network storage technologies and/or othertechnologies that can manage high-volume data access requests.

User interface 1506 can include input devices such as a touch pad, touchscreen, scroll wheel, click wheel, dial, button, switch, keypad,microphone, or the like, as well as output devices such as a videoscreen, indicator lights, speakers, headphone jacks, or the like,together with supporting electronics (e.g., digital-to-analog oranalog-to-digital converters, signal processors, or the like). In someembodiments, a user can operate input devices of user interface 1506 toinvoke the functionality of computer system 1500 and can view and/orhear output from computer system 1500 via output devices of userinterface 1506. In instances where computer system 1500 implements aserver, user interface 1506 can be remotely located with respect toprocessing subsystem 1502 and/or storage subsystem 1504.

Processing subsystem 1502 can be implemented using one or moreintegrated circuits, e.g., one or more single-core or multi-coremicroprocessors or microcontrollers, examples of which are known in theart. In operation, processing subsystem 1502 can control the operationof computer system 1500. In various embodiments, processing subsystem1502 can execute a variety of programs in response to program code andcan maintain multiple concurrently executing programs or processes. Atany given time, some or all of the program code to be executed can beresident in processing subsystem 1502 and/or in storage media such asstorage subsystem 1504.

Through suitable programming, processing subsystem 1502 can providevarious functionality for computer system 1500. For example, wherecomputer system 1500 implements a server of relay service 300,processing subsystem 1502 can implement various processes (or portionsthereof) described above as being implemented by any or all ofcertificate server 310, identity server 320, accessory courier server330, controller courier serve 340, message passing server(s) 350, passserver 360, and/or reporting server 370. Processing subsystem 1502 canalso execute other programs to control other functions of computersystem 1500, including programs that may be stored in storage subsystem1504.

Network communication interface 1508 can provide voice and/or datacommunication capability for computer system 1500. In some embodiments,network communication interface 1508 can include radio frequency (RF)transceiver components for accessing wireless data networks (e.g., usingdata network technology such as 3G, 4G/LTE, IEEE 802.11 family standards(e.g., Wi-Fi network technology), or other mobile communicationtechnologies, or any combination thereof), components for short-rangewireless communication (e.g., using Bluetooth and/or Bluetooth LEstandards, NFC, etc.), and/or other components. In some embodiments,network communication interface 1508 can provide wired networkconnectivity (e.g., Ethernet) in addition to or instead of a wirelessinterface. Network communication interface 1508 can be implemented usinga combination of hardware (e.g., driver circuits, antennas,modulators/demodulators, encoders/decoders, and other analog and/ordigital signal processing circuits) and software components. In someembodiments, network communication interface 1508 can support multiplecommunication channels concurrently, using the same transport ordifferent transports.

It will be appreciated that computer system 1500 is illustrative andthat variations and modifications are possible. Computer systemsincluding servers, controller devices, and/or accessories can havefunctionality not described herein (e.g., a controller device may alsoprovide voice communication via cellular telephone networks; ability tointeract with the user to provide personal information, play games,access content via the wireless network and/or locally stored content;etc.), and implementations of these devices and servers can includecomponents appropriate to such functionality.

Further, while a computer system is described herein with reference toparticular blocks, it is to be understood that these blocks are definedfor convenience of description and are not intended to imply aparticular physical arrangement of component parts. Further, the blocksneed not correspond to physically distinct components. Blocks can beconfigured to perform various operations, e.g., by programming aprocessor or providing appropriate control circuitry, and various blocksmight or might not be reconfigurable depending on how the initialconfiguration is obtained. Embodiments of the present invention can berealized in a variety of apparatus including electronic devicesimplemented using any combination of circuitry and software.

Controllers and accessories described herein can be implemented inelectronic devices that can be of generally conventional design. Suchdevices can be adapted to communicate using a uniform accessory protocolthat supports command-and-control operations by which a controller (afirst electronic device) can control operation of an accessory (a secondelectronic device). In some instances, a device can combine features oraspects of a controller and an accessory, e.g., in the case of a proxyas described above.

FIG. 16 shows a simplified block diagram of a controller 1600 accordingto an embodiment of the present invention. Controller 1600 can implementany or all of the controller functions, behaviors, and capabilitiesdescribed herein, as well as other functions, behaviors, andcapabilities not expressly described. Controller 1600 can includeprocessing subsystem 1610, storage device 1612, user interface 1614,communication interface 1616, secure storage module 1618, andcryptographic logic module 1620. Controller 1600 can also include othercomponents (not explicitly shown) such as a battery, power controllers,and other components operable to provide various enhanced capabilities.In various embodiments, controller 1600 can be implemented in a desktopcomputer, laptop computer, tablet computer, smart phone, other mobilephone, wearable computing device, or other systems having any desiredform factor. Further, as noted above, controller 1600 can be implementedpartly in a base station and partly in a mobile unit that communicateswith the base station and provides a user interface.

Storage device 1612 can be implemented, e.g., using disk, flash memory,or any other non-transitory storage medium, or a combination of media,and can include volatile and/or non-volatile media. In some embodiments,storage device 1612 can store one or more application and/or operatingsystem programs to be executed by processing subsystem 1610, includingprograms to implement various operations described above as beingperformed by a controller. For example, storage device 1612 can store auniform controller application that can read an accessory descriptionrecord and generate a graphical user interface for controlling theaccessory based on information therein (e.g., as described inabove-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/614,914). Storage device1612 can also store program code executable to communicate with a relayservice, e.g., as described above. In some embodiments, portions (orall) of the controller functionality described herein can be implementedin operating system programs rather than applications. In someembodiments, storage device 1612 can also store apps designed forspecific accessories or specific categories of accessories (e.g., an IPcamera app to manage an IP camera accessory or a security app tointeract with door lock accessories).

User interface 1614 can include input devices such as a touch pad, touchscreen, scroll wheel, click wheel, dial, button, switch, keypad,microphone, or the like, as well as output devices such as a videoscreen, indicator lights, speakers, headphone jacks, or the like,together with supporting electronics (e.g., digital-to-analog oranalog-to-digital converters, signal processors, or the like). A usercan operate input devices of user interface 1614 to invoke thefunctionality of controller 1600 and can view and/or hear output fromcontroller 1600 via output devices of user interface 1614.

Processing subsystem 1610 can be implemented as one or more integratedcircuits, e.g., one or more single-core or multi-core microprocessors ormicrocontrollers, examples of which are known in the art. In operation,processing system 1610 can control the operation of controller 1600. Invarious embodiments, processing subsystem 1610 can execute a variety ofprograms in response to program code and can maintain multipleconcurrently executing programs or processes. At any given time, some orall of the program code to be executed can be resident in processingsubsystem 1610 and/or in storage media such as storage device 1612.

Through suitable programming, processing subsystem 1610 can providevarious functionality for controller 1600. For example, in someembodiments, processing subsystem 1610 can implement various processes(or portions thereof) described above as being implemented by acontroller. Processing subsystem 1610 can also execute other programs tocontrol other functions of controller 1600, including applicationprograms that may be stored in storage device 1612. In some embodiments,these application programs may interact with an accessory, e.g., bygenerating messages to be sent to the accessory and/or receivingresponses from the accessory. Such interactions can be facilitated by anaccessory management daemon and/or other operating system processes,e.g., as described above, and can include communicating with theaccessory via a relay service as described above.

Communication interface 1616 can provide voice and/or data communicationcapability for controller 1600. In some embodiments communicationinterface 1616 can include radio frequency (RF) transceiver componentsfor accessing wireless voice and/or data networks (e.g., using cellulartelephone technology, data network technology such as 3G, 4G/LTE, Wi-Fi,other IEEE 802.11 family standards, or other mobile communicationtechnologies, or any combination thereof), components for short-rangewireless communication (e.g., using Bluetooth and/or Bluetooth LEstandards, NFC, etc.), and/or other components. In some embodimentscommunication interface 1616 can provide wired network connectivity(e.g., Ethernet) in addition to or instead of a wireless interface.Communication interface 1616 can be implemented using a combination ofhardware (e.g., driver circuits, antennas, modulators/demodulators,encoders/decoders, and other analog and/or digital signal processingcircuits) and software components. In some embodiments, communicationinterface 1616 can support multiple communication channels concurrentlyor at different times, using the same transport or different transports.Thus, for example, controller 1600 can communicate with accessories viaa local channel at some times and via a relay service at other times.

Secure storage module 1618 can be an integrated circuit or the like thatcan securely store cryptographic information for controller 1600.Examples of information that can be stored within secure storage module1618 include the controller's long-term public and secret keys 1622(LTPKC, LTSKC), a list of local pairings 1624 (e.g., a lookup table thatmaps a local accessory identifier to an accessory long-term public key(LTPKA) for accessories that have completed a local pair setup or pairadd process, e.g., as described above, with controller 1600), and a listof relay pairings 1626 (e.g., accessory RAs and associated access tokensfor accessories that have established a relay pairing, e.g., asdescribed above, with controller 1600). In some embodiments, pairinginformation can be stored such that a local pairing 1624 is mapped tothe corresponding relay pairing 1626 in instances where both a localpairing and a relay pairing with the accessory have been established.

In some embodiments, cryptographic operations can be implemented in acryptographic logic module 1620 that communicates with secure storagemodule 1618. Physically, cryptographic logic module 1620 can beimplemented in the same integrated circuit with secure storage module1618 or a different integrated circuit (e.g., a processor in processingsubsystem 1610) as desired. Cryptographic logic module 1620 can includevarious logic circuits (fixed or programmable as desired) that implementor support cryptographic operations of controller 1600, including any orall cryptographic operations described above. Secure storage module 1618and/or cryptographic logic module 1620 can appear as a “black box” tothe rest of controller 1600. Thus, for instance, communication interface1616 can receive a message in encrypted form that it cannot decrypt andcan simply deliver the message to processing subsystem 1610. Processingsubsystem 1610 may also be unable to decrypt the message, but it canrecognize the message as encrypted and deliver it to cryptographic logicmodule 1620. Cryptographic logic module 1620 can decrypt the message(e.g., using information extracted from secure storage module 1618) anddetermine what information to return to processing subsystem 1610. As aresult, certain information can be available only within secure storagemodule 1618 and cryptographic logic module 1620. If secure storagemodule 1618 and cryptographic logic module 1620 are implemented on asingle integrated circuit that executes code only from an internalsecure repository, this can make extraction of the information extremelydifficult, which can provide a high degree of security. Otherimplementations are also possible.

FIG. 17 shows a simplified block diagram of an accessory 1700 accordingto an embodiment of the present invention. Accessory 1700 can implementany or all of the accessory functions, behaviors, and capabilitiesdescribed herein, as well as other functions, behaviors, andcapabilities not expressly described. Accessory 1700 can include storagedevice 1728, processing subsystem 1730, user interface 1732,accessory-specific hardware 1734, communication interface 1736, securestorage module 1738, and cryptographic logic module 1740. Accessory 1700can also include other components (not explicitly shown) such as abattery, power controllers, and other components operable to providevarious enhanced capabilities.

Accessory 1700 is representative of a broad class of accessories thatcan be operated by a controller such as controller 1600, and suchaccessories can vary widely in capability, complexity, and form factor.Various accessories may include components not explicitly shown in FIG.17, including but not limited to storage devices (disk, flash memory,etc.) with fixed or removable storage media; video screens, speakers, orports for connecting to external audio/video devices; camera componentssuch as lenses, image sensors, and controls for same (e.g., aperture,zoom, exposure time, frame rate, etc.); microphones for recording audio(either alone or in connection with video recording); and so on.

Storage device 1728 can be implemented, e.g., using disk, flash memory,or any other non-transitory storage medium, or a combination of media,and can include volatile and/or non-volatile media. In some embodiments,storage device 1728 can store one or more programs (e.g., firmware) tobe executed by processing subsystem 1730, including programs toimplement various operations described above as being performed by anaccessory, as well as operations related to particular accessorybehaviors. Storage device 1728 can also store an accessory object oraccessory definition record that can be furnished to controller devices,e.g., during device discovery as described in above-referenced U.S.application Ser. No. 14/614,914. Storage device 1728 can also storeaccessory state information and any other data that may be used duringoperation of accessory 1700. Storage device 1728 can also store programcode executable to communicate with a relay service, e.g., as describedabove.

Processing subsystem 1730 can include, e.g., one or more single-core ormulti-core microprocessors and/or microcontrollers executing programcode to perform various functions associated with accessory 1700. Forexample, processing subsystem 1730 can implement various processes (orportions thereof) described above as being implemented by an accessory,e.g., by executing program code stored in storage device 1728.Processing subsystem 1730 can also execute other programs to controlother functions of accessory 1700. In some instances programs executedby processing subsystem 1730 can interact with a controller (e.g.,controller 1600), e.g., by generating messages to be sent to thecontroller and/or receiving messages from the controller. In someinstances, the messages can be sent and/or received using a relayservice as described above.

User interface 1732 may include user-operable input devices such as atouch pad, touch screen, scroll wheel, click wheel, dial, button,switch, keypad, microphone, or the like, as well as output devices suchas a video screen, indicator lights, speakers, headphone jacks, or thelike, together with supporting electronics (e.g., digital-to-analog oranalog-to-digital converters, signal processors, or the like). Dependingon the implementation of a particular accessory 1700, a user can operateinput devices of user interface 1732 to invoke functionality ofaccessory 1700 and can view and/or hear output from accessory 1700 viaoutput devices of user interface 1732. Some accessories may provide aminimal or no user interface. Where the accessory does not have a userinterface, a user can still interact with the accessory using acontroller (e.g., controller 1600).

Accessory-specific hardware 1734 can include any other components thatmay be present in accessory 1700 to enable its functionality. Forexample, in various embodiments accessory-specific hardware 1734 caninclude one or more storage devices using fixed or removable storagemedia; GPS receiver; power supply and/or power management circuitry; acamera; a microphone; one or more actuators; control switches;environmental sensors (e.g., temperature sensor, pressure sensor,accelerometer, chemical sensor, etc.); and so on. It is to be understoodthat any type of accessory functionality can be supported by providingappropriate accessory-specific hardware 1734 and that accessory-specifichardware can include mechanical as well as electrical or electroniccomponents.

Communication interface 1736 can provide voice and/or data communicationcapability for accessory 1700. In some embodiments communicationinterface 1736 can include radio frequency (RF) transceiver componentsfor accessing wireless voice and/or data networks (e.g., using cellulartelephone technology, data network technology such as 3G, 4G/LTE, Wi-Fi,other IEEE 802.11 family standards, or other mobile communicationtechnologies, or any combination thereof), components for short-rangewireless communication (e.g., using Bluetooth and/or Bluetooth LEstandards, NFC, etc.), and/or other components. In some embodimentscommunication interface 1736 can provide wired network connectivity(e.g., Ethernet) in addition to or instead of a wireless interface.Communication interface 1736 can be implemented using a combination ofhardware (e.g., driver circuits, antennas, modulators/demodulators,encoders/decoders, and other analog and/or digital signal processingcircuits) and software components. In some embodiments, communicationinterface 1736 can support multiple communication channels concurrentlyor at different times, using the same transport or different transports.Thus, for example, accessory 1700 can communicate with a controller viaa local channel at some times and via a relay service at other times.

Secure storage module 1738 can be an integrated circuit or the like thatcan securely store cryptographic information for accessory 1700.Examples of information that can be stored within secure storage module1738 include the accessory's long-term public and secret keys 1742(LTPKA, LTSKA), a list of local pairings 1744 (e.g., a lookup table thatmaps a local controller identifier to a controller long-term public key(LTPKC) for controllers that have completed a local pair setup or pairadd process, e.g., as described above, with accessory 1700), and a listof relay pairings 1746 (e.g., controller RAs and associated accesstokens for controllers that have established a relay pairing, e.g., asdescribed above, with accessory 1700). In some embodiments, pairinginformation can be stored such that a local pairing 1744 is mapped tothe corresponding relay pairing 1746 in instances where both a localpairing and a relay pairing with the controller have been established.In some embodiments, secure storage module 4038 can be omitted; keys andlists of paired controllers can be stored in storage device 1728.

In some embodiments, cryptographic operations can be implemented in acryptographic logic module 1740 that communicates with secure storagemodule 1738. Physically, cryptographic logic module 1740 can beimplemented in the same integrated circuit with secure storage module1738 or a different integrated circuit (e.g., a processor in processingsubsystem 1730) as desired. Cryptographic logic module 1740 can includevarious logic circuits (fixed or programmable as desired) that implementor support cryptographic operations of accessory 1700, including any orall cryptographic operations described above. Secure storage module 1738and/or cryptographic logic module 1740 can appear as a “black box” tothe rest of accessory 1700. Thus, for instance, communication interface1736 can receive a message in encrypted form that it cannot decrypt andcan simply deliver the message to processing subsystem 1730. Processingsubsystem 1730 may also be unable to decrypt the message, but it canrecognize the message as encrypted and deliver it to cryptographic logicmodule 1740. Cryptographic logic module 1740 can decrypt the message(e.g., using information extracted from secure storage module 1738) anddetermine what information to return to processing subsystem 1730. As aresult, certain information can be available only within secure storagemodule 1738 and cryptographic logic module 1740. If secure storagemodule 1738 and cryptographic logic module 1740 are implemented on asingle integrated circuit that executes code only from an internalsecure repository, this can make extraction of the information extremelydifficult, which can provide a high degree of security. Otherimplementations are also possible.

Accessory 1700 can be any electronic apparatus that interacts withcontroller 1600. In some embodiments, controller 1600 can provide remotecontrol over operations of accessory 1700 as described above. Forexample controller 1600 can provide a remote user interface foraccessory 1700 that can include both input and output controls (e.g., adisplay screen to display current status information obtained fromaccessory 1700 and an input control such as a touchscreen overlay toallow changes to the status information). Controller 1600 in variousembodiments can control any function of accessory 1700 and can alsoreceive data from accessory 1700, via a local channel or a relayservice.

It will be appreciated that the system configurations and componentsdescribed herein are illustrative and that variations and modificationsare possible. It is to be understood that an implementation ofcontroller 1600 can perform all operations described above as beingperformed by a controller and that an implementation of accessory 1700can perform any or all operations described above as being performed byan accessory. A proxy, bridge, tunnel, or coordinator can combinecomponents of controller 1600 and accessory 1700, using the samehardware or different hardware as desired. The controller and/oraccessory may have other capabilities not specifically described herein(e.g., mobile phone, global positioning system (GPS), broadband datacommunication, Internet connectivity, etc.). Depending onimplementation, the devices can interoperate to provide anyfunctionality supported by either (or both) devices or to providefunctionality that is partly implemented in each device. In someembodiments, a particular accessory can have some functionality that isnot accessible or invocable via a particular controller but isaccessible via another controller or by interacting directly with theaccessory.

Further, while the controller and accessory are described herein withreference to particular blocks, it is to be understood that these blocksare defined for convenience of description and are not intended to implya particular physical arrangement of component parts. Further, theblocks need not correspond to physically distinct components. Blocks canbe configured to perform various operations, e.g., by programming aprocessor or providing appropriate control circuitry, and various blocksmight or might not be reconfigurable depending on how the initialconfiguration is obtained. Embodiments of the present invention can berealized in a variety of apparatus including electronic devicesimplemented using any combination of circuitry and software.

Further Embodiments

While the invention has been described with respect to specificembodiments, one skilled in the art will recognize that numerousmodifications are possible. A relay service as described herein canallow any number of controllers (belonging to any number of users) tocommunicate with any number of accessories. In some embodiments, acontroller can have access to an environment model that containsinformation about a set of accessories within an environment where thecontroller is frequently present (e.g., the user's home). Theenvironment model can be constructed, e.g., by an admin controller, asthe user adds accessories. In some embodiments, the environment modelcan associate an accessory RA and a local accessory identifier withidentifying information (e.g., manufacturer, model number, serialnumber, firmware version, user-friendly name, etc.) for a specificaccessory that is present in the environment. The controller can use themodel to present an intuitive interface to the various accessories inthe environment, sparing the user the need to know anything aboutaccessory RAs or local accessory identifiers. The interface can also beindependent of whether the controller is currently present in or absentfrom the local environment, or whether communication with a particularaccessory is via a local channel or the relay service. To facilitateoperations such as adding and removing relay pairings (or localpairings), a controller may present an interface that allows the user tointeract with the environment model as a whole. For example, the usercan instruct the controller to add a relay pairing between anothercontroller (or another user account) and the environment model or someportion of the environment model (e.g., accessories in a particular roomdefined by the model). The controller can interpret this as aninstruction to add a relay pairing between the user account and eachaccessory represented in the environment model (or portion thereof).Accordingly, in connection with process 1000 described above, thecontroller can automatically generate a request to the new controller toconsent to a relay pairing for each accessory RA in the environmentmodel (or portion thereof). It should be noted that communications withrelay service 300 can simply include a list of accessory RAs, and relayservice 300 does not need to have access to any other information thatmay be included in an environment model. Nor does relay service 300 needto know whether a list of accessory RAs it receives is exhaustive of allaccessories in a particular environment. In some embodiments, theenvironment model can be shared between controllers authorized to accessit, e.g., using synchronization operations as described inabove-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,912, and a controllerthat obtains relay pairings via an admin controller (e.g., via process1000 described above) can use the shared environment model to associatethe accessory RAs with specific accessories in the environment.

Embodiments described above allow a relay service to operate withoutretaining any information as to the types and/or functionalities of theaccessories that can be controlled by a particular controller. Asdescribed above, the relay service can assign a relay alias to eachaccessory in a manner such that the relay alias reveals no informationabout the accessory's identity (e.g., make, manufacturer), functionality(e.g., door lock, light bulb, refrigerator, etc.), or physical location(including a relative location within an environment such as aparticular room as well as absolute geographical position). Thus, evenin the event that an unauthorized party succeeds in obtaininginformation from relay service 300 described above, the informationwould be limited. For instance, it may be possible to determine fromtoken repository 322 how many accessories a particular operator RA cancontrol but not what any of those accessories actually do or where theymight be found. Further security is provided in that controllers can berequired to authenticate with relay service 300 prior to sendingmessages to an accessory, in that controllers can only send a message toan accessory if they have a valid access token for the accessory RA (andvice versa) and in that the controller and accessory can establishend-to-end encryption independently of relay service 300.

An accessory treated as an “endpoint accessory” from the perspective ofthe relay service can in some cases be a proxy capable of relayingmessages to other accessories within the local environment, e.g., asdescribed in above-referenced U.S. application Ser. No. 14/725,891.Thus, for instance, a low-power accessory does not need to maintain aconnection to the accessory courier server; a proxy in the localenvironment with the low-power accessory can maintain the connection tothe relay service and can locally connect with the low-power accessoryas needed to communicate any messages received from the relay service.

As noted above, an access token can have an expiration date set when itis created. In some embodiments, the expiration date can default to astandard value (e.g., 1 week or 1 month after creation). In someembodiments, the user creating an access token (e.g., an admin user) canspecify an expiration date for the token (e.g., to grant limited-timeaccess to somebody who is house-sitting, etc.). Verifying the accesstoken can include checking the expiration date and invalidating thetoken if the date has passed.

In some embodiments, various servers and operations provided by therelay service can be accessed through a common addressing scheme. Forexample, all communications from accessories can be sent as HTTPrequests addressed to a single Internet domain name (e.g.,relay-service.service-provider-name.com); the message can specify arelative URL for the appropriate server (e.g., a GET request to relativeURL “/id” can be used to obtain an accessory RA, a POST request torelative URL “/connect” can be used to establish a connection to theaccessory courier server, and so on).

Various features described herein, e.g., methods, apparatus,computer-readable media and the like, can be realized using anycombination of dedicated components and/or programmable processorsand/or other programmable devices. The various processes describedherein can be implemented on the same processor or different processorsin any combination. Where components are described as being configuredto perform certain operations, such configuration can be accomplished,e.g., by designing electronic circuits to perform the operation, byprogramming programmable electronic circuits (such as microprocessors)to perform the operation, or any combination thereof. Further, while theembodiments described above may make reference to specific hardware andsoftware components, those skilled in the art will appreciate thatdifferent combinations of hardware and/or software components may alsobe used and that particular operations described as being implemented inhardware might also be implemented in software or vice versa.

Computer programs incorporating various features described herein may beencoded and stored on various computer readable storage media; suitablemedia include magnetic disk or tape, optical storage media such ascompact disk (CD) or DVD (digital versatile disk), flash memory, andother non-transitory media. Computer readable media encoded with theprogram code may be packaged with a compatible electronic device, or theprogram code may be provided separately from electronic devices (e.g.,via Internet download or as a separately packaged computer-readablestorage medium).

Thus, although the invention has been described with respect to specificembodiments, it will be appreciated that the invention is intended tocover all modifications and equivalents within the scope of thefollowing claims.

What is claimed is:
 1. A method, comprising: analyzing an activity logof a relay service, the activity log including a record ofcommunications between a plurality of controllers each identified by adifferent operator relay alias and a plurality of accessories eachidentified by a different accessory relay alias; identifying, based atleast in part on the analyzing of the activity log, a pattern ofanomalous activity, the pattern involving at least a threshold number ofdifferent operator relay aliases; generating an investigation requestfor each of the operator relay aliases identified within the pattern ofanomalous activity as determined from the activity log, theinvestigation request including one or more accessory relay aliases withwhich the operator relay alias communicated; receiving, at a reportingserver of the relay service, responses to at least some of theinvestigation requests, the responses including accessory identifyinginformation; detecting, based at least in part on the responses, aspecific accessory type correlated with the pattern of anomalousactivity; and performing a follow up action based at least in part onthe detected specific accessory type.
 2. The method of claim 1, whereinthe accessory identifying information includes one or more of: amanufacturer name, a model name, a hardware version, a firmware version,or a software version.
 3. The method of claim 1 wherein initiating afollow up action includes one or more of: adding the specific accessorytype to a blacklist such that accessories of the specific accessory typeare blocked from connecting to the relay service; or notifying amanufacturer of accessories of the specific accessory type that thespecific accessory type is correlated with the pattern of anomalousactivity.
 4. The method of claim 1, further comprising: applyingstatistical algorithms to define a baseline pattern of accessorybehavior and accessory relay aliases; and determining a deviation fromthe baseline pattern to identify the pattern of anomalous activity. 5.The method of claim 1, further comprising: analyzing performance metricsassociated with various servers in a relay service network trafficpattern to detect the pattern of anomalous activity.
 6. The method ofclaim 1, further comprising: identifying a number of accessoriesassociated with different relay aliases; determining if the numberexceeds a threshold number; and identifying if the number exceeds thethreshold number as the pattern of anomalous activity.
 7. The method ofclaim 1, wherein the responses do not include the operator relay aliasor the accessory relay alias.
 8. A reporting server, comprising: amemory configured to store computer-executable instructions; and one ormore processors in communication with the memory and configured toexecute the computer-executable instructions to at least: analyze anactivity log of a relay service, the activity log including a record ofcommunications between a plurality of controllers each identified by adifferent operator relay alias and a plurality of accessories eachidentified by a different accessory relay alias; identify, based atleast in part on the analyzing of the activity log, a pattern ofanomalous activity, the pattern involving at least a threshold number ofdifferent operator relay aliases; generate an investigation request foreach of the operator relay aliases identified within the pattern ofanomalous activity as determined from the activity log, theinvestigation request including one or more accessory relay aliases withwhich the operator relay alias communicated; receive, at a reportingserver of the relay service, responses to at least some of theinvestigation requests, the responses including accessory identifyinginformation; detect, based at least in part on the responses, a specificaccessory type correlated with the pattern of anomalous activity; andperform a follow up action based at least in part on the detectedspecific accessory type.
 9. The reporting server of claim 8, wherein theaccessory identifying information includes one or more of: amanufacturer name, a model name, a hardware version, a firmware version,or a software version.
 10. The reporting server of claim 8, whereininitiating a follow up action includes one or more of: adding thespecific accessory type to a blacklist such that accessories of thespecific accessory type are blocked from connecting to the relayservice; or notifying a manufacturer of accessories of the specificaccessory type that the specific accessory type is correlated with thepattern of anomalous activity.
 11. The reporting server of claim 8,further comprising instructions to at least: apply statisticalalgorithms to define a baseline pattern of accessory behavior andaccessory relay aliases; and determine a deviation from the baselinepattern to identify the pattern of anomalous activity.
 12. The reportingserver of claim 8, further comprising instructions to at least: analyzeperformance metrics associated with various servers in a relay servicenetwork traffic pattern to detect the pattern of anomalous activity. 13.The reporting server of claim 8, further comprising instructions to atleast: identifying a number of accessories associated with differentrelay aliases; determining if the number exceeds a threshold number; andidentifying if the number exceeds the threshold number as the pattern ofanomalous activity.
 14. The reporting server of claim 8, wherein theresponses do not include the operator relay alias or the accessory relayalias.
 15. A computer-readable storage medium storingcomputer-executable instructions that, when executed by a reportingserver, perform operations, comprising: analyzing an activity log of arelay service, the activity log including a record of communicationsbetween a plurality of controllers each identified by a differentoperator relay alias and a plurality of accessories each identified by adifferent accessory relay alias; identifying, based at least in part onthe analyzing of the activity log, a pattern of anomalous activity, thepattern involving at least a threshold number of different operatorrelay aliases; generating an investigation request for each of theoperator relay aliases identified within the pattern of anomalousactivity as determined from the activity log, the investigation requestincluding one or more accessory relay aliases with which the operatorrelay alias communicated; receiving, at a reporting server of the relayservice, responses to at least some of the investigation requests, theresponses including accessory identifying information; detecting, basedat least in part on the responses, a specific accessory type correlatedwith the pattern of anomalous activity; and performing a follow upaction based at least in part on the detected specific accessory type.16. The computer-readable storage medium of claim 15, wherein theaccessory identifying information includes one or more of: amanufacturer name, a model name, a hardware version, a firmware version,or a software version.
 17. The computer-readable storage medium of claim15, wherein initiating a follow up action includes one or more of:adding the specific accessory type to a blacklist such that accessoriesof the specific accessory type are blocked from connecting to the relayservice; or notifying a manufacturer of accessories of the specificaccessory type that the specific accessory type is correlated with thepattern of anomalous activity.
 18. The computer-readable storage mediumof claim 15, wherein the operations further comprise: applyingstatistical algorithms to define a baseline pattern of accessorybehavior and accessory relay aliases; and determining a deviation fromthe baseline pattern to identify the pattern of anomalous activity. 19.The computer-readable storage medium of claim 15, wherein the operationsfurther comprise: analyzing performance metrics associated with variousservers in a relay service network traffic pattern to detect the patternof anomalous activity.
 20. The computer-readable storage medium of claim15, wherein the operations further comprise: identifying a number ofaccessories associated with different relay aliases; determining if thenumber exceeds a threshold number; and identifying if the number exceedsthe threshold number as the pattern of anomalous activity.